Doctor's clinic · 5 min read

Should a government doctor give up the non-practising allowance to practise privately?

The short answer

Where a state bars private practice, it pays government doctors a non-practising allowance, a percentage of basic pay, and some states let a doctor decline it in order to practise. Whether giving it up pays depends on your state's rule, your basic pay and what an evening clinic would clear after tax. Reports show the rate has been a quarter of basic pay and then a fifth, varies by state and has been changed in several. Read your own state's current order before deciding, because a doctor who declines it may not be able to claim it back later.

Not sure about your case? Ask an expert, free ↓

The allowance that arrives without asking

A medical officer in a district hospital sees a colleague open an evening clinic near the bus stand and wonders about his own position. His payslip shows a line called NPA that he never thought about. He asks the accounts clerk what it would be worth to him per year and whether he could drop it, and the clerk shrugs. His question is a good one, and the answer is in his state's own order, not in a general guide.

This page explains the logic and the numbers to compare. It cannot give your state's figure. We found reports of rates and rulings, but no single current official table across states; where we say what has been reported, the date is old, and the research found no 2025 or 2026 confirmation of a national change. General information, not legal advice.

What the allowance is

  • A payment for not practising privately. It is paid in states where government doctors are barred from private practice, as a percentage of basic pay.
  • Health is a state subject. The central government's own answer in Parliament says states decide NPA eligibility for their own doctors; central rates and ceilings are a separate matter.
  • The rate has changed over time. The rate has been revised with pay commissions and states follow at different times; Haryana, for example, is reported to pay 20% of basic pay from May 2018 (20% of basic pay). Punjab was reported at 25%, and later reduced. Treat all of that as history to check, not as a present rate.
  • Some states banned private practice outright. Telangana was reported in 2022 to have barred private practice for new state recruits, with doctors demanding an allowance.
  • NPA is part of basic pay for some purposes. A Gujarat High Court ruling, reported, treats it so for certain benefits, which matters for pension and other allowances.

Because these are reports, the next step for you is the state government's order or the service rules your department gave you. Ask your establishment clerk for the latest government order on NPA and on private practice in writing.

How to compare the two

A method, not a rate. Your state's order supplies the numbers for steps 1 and 2.
StepWhat to work out
1Your yearly NPA: percentage of basic pay in your order, times twelve, plus what it adds to dearness allowance and other pay-linked items
2What the allowance does to your pension and other benefits, if your state treats it as part of pay
3What an evening clinic would clear, using what a clinic keeps with your fee and a realistic patient count for the hours you can give
4Subtract the clinic's setup and reserve (cost to open) and tax on the clinic's profit
5Compare the two for years one to three, not month one. The clinic builds slowly
6Check what you give up if you ever want it back

A Rajasthan High Court ruling, reported, held that doctors who voluntarily declined the allowance could not later seek pay parity with juniors who accepted it. That is the practical warning: giving it up may be a one-way decision.

An illustration

A medical officer has a basic pay of Rs 80,000 a month and an allowance of 20% of it, or Rs 16,000 a month and Rs 1.92 lakh a year (illustrative figures, not any state's table). An evening clinic of three hours a day, six days a week, at 4 patients an evening and a fee of Rs 300, collects about Rs 31,000 a month, from which room rent and a helper come off. The allowance is steady and taxed as salary; the clinic is uncertain, and only beats the allowance once the evenings fill and the costs stay low. So the choice is between a steady allowance and a clinic that has to grow into more than it starts with.

The counter case: a doctor who wants to build a full-time practice, and whose allowance is small compared with what a busy clinic would clear, gives up the allowance and the job together. Our worked examples put a tier-2 GP at about Rs 60,000 a month before tax at 15 patients a day, so the comparison is between a defined allowance and a clinic that must reach that count; see patients to break even.

What usually goes wrong

  • Practising privately while drawing the allowance, which is the situation the allowance exists to prevent.
  • Declining the allowance on the strength of a colleague's story, without reading the order or the court rulings in your state.
  • Forgetting that a government job may also ask for permission for any outside work, whether or not private practice is barred.
  • Underestimating how long the clinic takes to match the allowance and the salary around it.
  • Not recording the choice in writing with the department.

Apply this to your own case

Get your state's current order on NPA and private practice, your last payslip and your service rules. Run the six steps above on a sheet. If the clinic would only break even by year three, the allowance is the safer cash. If it would clearly pass the allowance by year two, and the order lets you decline it, still ask what you would give up. If you want a person to read the order with you, use the form at the foot of the page. For the wider question of whether to keep the job and build a clinic in the evenings, see clinic or hospital job.

Questions people ask

How much is NPA?

It is a percentage of basic pay set by the state. Reports have put it at a quarter and at a fifth in different states and years, so check your own order.

Can a government doctor run a private clinic?

It depends on the state and on the service rules. Where private practice is barred, the doctor receives the allowance; some states allow limited private practice and some allow opting out of the allowance.

Can I get the allowance back after declining it?

Not necessarily. A reported Rajasthan High Court ruling held that doctors who declined it could not later claim parity with those who took it.

This is general information, not tax or financial advice. Check your own numbers with a chartered accountant.

Where these numbers come from

  1. Haryana pays doctors non-practising allowance at 20% of basic pay, applied from 1 May 2018 (as reported; other states and the central scale differ, check your state's order): 20% of basic pay (Haryana). Reported: Medical Dialogues: Haryana to give NPA at 20 percent to doctors, checked 14 November 2026.

Fees, rates and rents change. Check the official source before you pay or sign anything.

Money and tax · Doctor's clinic

More on money and tax for a doctor's clinic

21 pages on this. You are on number 13.

  1. What does a clinic spend every month: rent, staff, consumables, power, software?
  2. How many patients a day does my clinic need to break even, at my fee?
  3. Should a government doctor give up the non-practising allowance to practise privately?
  4. After rent, staff and everything else, what does a clinic really keep? A typical month
  5. Which specialties are cheap to start (GP, psychiatry, paediatrics) and which need lakhs in equipment?
  6. How do I issue GST bills for products or cosmetic services I sell from the clinic?
  7. What should a clinic owner pay themselves, and how do I count my own time in the books?
  8. Should my clinic earn from selling medicines? What dispensing really adds
All 21 on money and tax →

Reading about it is one thing; doing it in your doctor's clinic is another. If you'd like a hand working out your own numbers, tell us where you are and a person will reply, free.

Get help with this ↓

What now?

Next question · 4 of 10 in Should I open my own clinic?Which specialties are cheap to start (GP, psychiatry, paediatrics) and which need lakhs in equipment? →

Where are you?

One tap, and we point you to the right next step.

Menu

Read

Ask an expert Ask an expertFree, real peopleHub
Ask an expert