D2C brand · 6 min read

How do I know if my D2C ads agency is working? Seven checks

The short answer

Ask for five things from your own store, not the agency's report: orders, revenue, ad spend, returns and refused COD parcels, for each week. Divide the spend by the orders you actually kept to get your real cost per customer, and compare it with what an order earns after product, shipping and fees. If the agency's numbers and your store's numbers keep disagreeing, or the cost per kept order only rises, that is your answer. Do the check every two weeks, not at the end of the contract.

Not sure about your case? Ask an expert, free ↓

The report said 4.1, the bank said otherwise

An owner opened the agency's monthly deck. Return on ad spend was 4.1, up from 3.6. Her Shopify showed fewer orders than the deck claimed, a quarter of the COD parcels had come back, and her cash had dropped. Both numbers were real. The platform counts a purchase the moment the order is placed; the courier and the customer decide later whether it stays.

This page is a set of checks you can run in an hour, with no technical skill, to see which of the two stories is true for your brand.

Seven checks

  1. Match the orders. Take the orders the ad platform says it brought and compare them with your store's orders in the same week. A gap is normal, because the platform counts differently. A gap that widens every month is not. Ask the agency to explain it in writing.
  2. Compute a real cost per customer. Ad spend divided by new customers whose orders were delivered and kept. Compare it with the reported ₹800–1,200 per new customer for blended costs, as a direction only, and above all with what one order leaves you.
  3. Work out what one order leaves. After product cost, shipping, packing, payment fees and your return and refusal losses. Reported COD return rates run 25–38% of COD orders against 2–5% of prepaid orders for prepaid orders. If your COD share is high, your real ad return is lower than the platform shows.
  4. Look at which orders came. If most come from steep discounts or from cash-on-delivery in towns where your courier struggles, the ads buy orders you may not keep.
  5. Ask how many new creatives were made and tested. Ads that do not change tire. If the same three videos run for two months, results usually slide.
  6. Check the structure. One campaign for everything, or several for different products and audiences? Ask what was tested last month and what was learned.
  7. Check the spend rule. Is there a daily cap, and a rule for pausing a campaign that loses money? If not, you are trusting a person with your cash without a limit.

Why the platform's figure and yours differ

Ad platforms credit a sale to an ad using their own rules about when someone saw or clicked it. Your store counts the orders that arrived. Neither knows about returns, failed deliveries and refusals at the door, which is where a lot of Indian D2C money leaks. A fair agency report shows both figures and the reason for the gap. A report that shows only the platform's number is incomplete.

A simple habit helps: every Monday, write down last week's ad spend and the number of orders delivered and not returned. Divide. That figure, week after week, is more honest than any dashboard, and it is yours.

What to ask in the review call

  • What changed in the account this fortnight, and why?
  • Which three creatives brought the most orders that were kept, and what will replace them?
  • What did you test that did not work?
  • What do you need from me: photos, offers, a faster reply on stock?
  • If I doubled the budget, what would you expect to happen to cost per order, and what evidence do you have?

A good agency answers with specifics and sometimes with bad news. A weak one answers with reach and impressions. You can also ask who is on the account and how many brands they handle: a person managing many accounts has little time for yours.

When to end it

Give a clear brief and a fair run first: a new account needs a few weeks of learning. After that, consider ending the contract when three things are true together: your real cost per kept order has risen for two review periods, the agency cannot show what it tried to fix it, and your own checks find the platform number much higher than the store's. Check the notice period and who owns the ad account before you say anything. Take back admin access, export your audiences and creatives, and move the pixel and billing to your own login.

If you decide to bring ads in-house instead, agency or in-house sets out when that makes sense.

If you are small, if you are large

Small. With small spend there is not enough data to judge anyone in two weeks. Judge on the process: are they testing, do they share both numbers, do they respond. Large. Ask for an outside check of the account from a person you trust, or an independent audit once a year. At large spend, even a small drift in cost per order is a lot of money.

What usually goes wrong

  • Judging by reach, clicks and platform ROAS alone.
  • Not telling the agency about returns and COD refusals, so it cannot optimise for them.
  • Changing the product, price and offer mid-contract and then blaming or praising the agency.
  • Accepting reports with no weekly breakdown, only monthly totals.
  • Letting the agency keep the ad account and the audiences in its own name.
  • Staying in a bad contract because ending it feels rude.

Apply it to your brand

If the numbers do not add up and you cannot tell why, send us the last three months of spend and delivered orders and we will help you read them. This is general information.

Questions people ask

How long should I give an agency before deciding?

A new account needs a few weeks to learn, so judge the first month on process and the second and third on cost per kept order. A three-month trial with fortnightly reviews is a common structure.

What is a good ROAS for a D2C brand?

There is no single good number. It depends on your margin, returns and COD share, which is why the page on break-even ROAS works it out from your own order. A high ROAS on orders that return is worth little.

Can I switch agencies without losing my audiences?

If the ad account, pixel and store are in your name, yes. If they are in the agency's name, you may have to rebuild. Settle ownership before you start.

Should my agency see my margins?

Share at least the contribution per order and the return rate, so it can aim at orders you keep. If you do not trust the agency with that, that is a finding in itself.

Where these numbers come from

  1. Blended customer acquisition cost: ₹800–1,200 per new customer (India; a 35-brand scan, direction only; one series runs ₹650 to ₹1,850 over 2021 to 25). Reported: The CPG Lab (Substack) (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.
  2. RTO rate on COD orders across sources: 25–38% of COD orders (all India; Razorpay 25 to 30, ClickPost 37.5, other vendors 28 to 35; vendor blogs, not audited). Reported: Razorpay blog (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.
  3. RTO rate on prepaid orders across sources: 2–5% of prepaid orders (all India; vendor blogs; one vendor shows 20 to 30, treated as an outlier). Reported: Shipprime (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.

Fees, rates and rents change. Check the official source before you pay or sign anything.

Team and hiring · D2C brand

More on team and hiring for a d2c brand

13 pages on this. You are on number 7.

  1. Ads agency or in-house for a D2C brand? What to choose at each size
  2. Is joining a D2C startup safe if its funding dries up? Questions to ask first
  3. How do I know if my D2C ads agency is working? Seven checks
  4. What does a growth, marketing or ops role pay at a small D2C brand?
  5. Can I start my own brand from what I learned at a D2C job? What is fair to use
  6. When does a D2C brand need a customer support person? Signs and set-up
  7. Hire packers or use a fulfilment partner for my D2C brand? How to choose
  8. How to split equity with a co-founder in a D2C brand: what to agree first
All 13 on team and hiring →

Reading about it is one thing; doing it in your d2c brand is another. If you'd like a hand building and running your team, tell us where you are and a person will reply, free.

Get help with this ↓

What now?

Next question · 4 of 13 in Who to hire and whenWhen does a D2C brand need a customer support person? Signs and set-up →

Where are you?

One tap, and we point you to the right next step.

Menu

Read

Ask an expert Ask an expertFree, real peopleHub
Ask an expert