Two numbers, one counter
One blog says loose dal and spices earn you 15 to 30 per cent. Another, written for shops like yours, says the margin on loose goods is low. You stand at the sack of toor dal with a scoop, and you know both are partly right. The honest answer starts with what the margin is measured on, and then with what leaves the sack besides the customer's bag.
Why the sources differ
- Gross or net. One source gives gross margin on selling price. The other does not say whether it is gross or net. A gross figure ignores what is lost; a net one includes it.
- Which goods. Spices carry more margin than rice or sugar. A cash-and-carry MD, in 2022, put the kirana's margins this way: oil and sugar 1%; spices 15%.
- Weight loss. A sack you buy at 50 kg does not sell as 50 kg. Spillage, moisture, pests and a scoop that is a little heavy shrink it.
- Time. Weighing and packing take a helper's time, which a margin figure does not show.
A worked sack
Take a 50 kg sack of dal bought for ₹5,000, which is ₹100 a kilo. These are our round numbers, not market prices. Sell it loose at ₹115 or ₹125 a kilo, and lose 0, 2 or 4 per cent of the weight along the way.
| Selling price | Weight lost | Revenue (₹) | Profit on the sack (₹) | Gross margin on sales |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ₹115 a kilo | 0% | 5,750 | 750 | 13.0% |
| ₹115 a kilo | 2% | 5,635 | 635 | 11.3% |
| ₹115 a kilo | 4% | 5,520 | 520 | 9.4% |
| ₹125 a kilo | 0% | 6,250 | 1,250 | 20.0% |
| ₹125 a kilo | 2% | 6,125 | 1,125 | 18.4% |
| ₹125 a kilo | 4% | 6,000 | 1,000 | 16.7% |
Read across: a 15 per cent mark-up before loss lands near 9 to 13 per cent after, which fits the lower source. A 25 per cent mark-up before loss lands in the high teens, which is close to the higher source. Both blogs can be right, depending on the price you can actually charge.
What you lose besides weight
- Tax is lower, but so is the paper trail. Loose staples carry 0% GST while the same goods pre-packed and labelled carry 5% GST. See GST for a kirana.
- Scale risk. A scale that reads heavy gives away margin; an unverified one risks ₹2,000–10,000 fine. See scale stamping.
- Price risk. Grain and oil prices move with the week, and stock bought at one rate sells at another.
- Spoilage. A bad lot or a damp corner can wipe a sack.
On the whole shop, published blends are 7–15% of sales; see margin by category. Loose goods are one part of that blend, not a way out of it.
How to find your own number
- Pick three loose items and weigh what you buy in.
- Record what you sell, in kilos and rupees, for a month.
- Weigh what is left. The gap between kilos in and kilos out plus left is your weight loss.
- Work margin on selling price after loss, and put a value on the helper's weighing time.
What usually goes wrong
- Reading a blog's gross margin as a take-home number.
- Never weighing what comes in against what goes out.
- Buying in a large sack to save on rate and losing more to spoilage than was saved.
- Packing in advance for convenience and moving into repacking rules. See repacking rules.
Margin ranges are published estimates from blogs, with no data behind them. Our worked sack uses round numbers of ours.
Your own sack
For how loose goods are handled legally, read loose goods rules. The type page on a provision store with loose staples lists the rest.
Questions people ask
Is loose selling more profitable than packed?
It can be, if you charge a higher price per kilo and keep weight loss small. It carries more work and more risk, so test it on three items first.
How much weight loss is normal?
We found no sourced figure. Our worked sack uses 0 to 4 per cent; weigh yours.
These are ballpark figures to plan with, not a forecast for your business. Your own quotes and numbers come first.
Where these numbers come from
- Gross margin on loose grains, pulses and spices, one source (another source says 5-10%: see kirana-store.margin-loose-chahra): 15–30% gross (India). Reported: Accountune, kirana store profit margin (31 Aug 2026; indicative ranges, vendor blog, no data), checked 14 November 2026.
- Margin on loose goods, other source (gross or net not stated; 'margin kam hota hai'): 5–10% (India, 14 May 2026). Reported: Chahra, kirana store business plan (14 May 2026), checked 14 November 2026.
- Kirana margin on oil and sugar; on spices (cash-and-carry MD, 2022): oil and sugar 1%; spices 15% (India). Reported: Outlook Business, interview with the MD of a cash-and-carry chain (1 Apr 2022), checked 14 November 2026.
- GST on loose rice, wheat, dal, atta, milk, paneer, eggs and vegetables: 0% GST (India, from 22 Sep 2025). Official source: West Bengal Commercial Taxes Directorate, consolidated GST rate chart of goods (16 Apr 2026; Notifications 9/2025 and 10/2025 CT (Rate), from 22 Sep 2025), checked 14 November 2026.
- GST on pre-packaged and labelled cereals, pulses and flour (pre-packed curd, lassi and buttermilk also 5%): 5% GST (India, from 22 Sep 2025). Official source: West Bengal Commercial Taxes Directorate, consolidated GST rate chart of goods (16 Apr 2026; Notifications 9/2025 and 10/2025 CT (Rate), from 22 Sep 2025), checked 14 November 2026.
- Use of an unverified weighing or measuring instrument (s.33): fine; a repeat adds jail up to 1 year: ₹2,000–10,000 fine (India). Official source: Legal Metrology Act 2009, s.33 (FAOLEX copy), checked 14 November 2026.
- Blended gross margin of a kirana (reading of 'high single digits to mid teens'; vendor blog, no data): 7–15% of sales (India). Reported: Accountune, kirana store profit margin (31 Aug 2026; indicative ranges, vendor blog, no data), checked 14 November 2026.
Fees, rates and rents change. Check the official source before you pay or sign anything.
What now?
Where are you?
One tap, and we point you to the right next step.