Read first
What is the comparison?
Ganesh owns a four-storey building near a tech park. A broker says flats will fetch a steady rent. Another says PG beds will fetch much more. He needs a sum, not a slogan.
| Rent as flats | Run a PG | Lease to an operator | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Work | Low: a tenant and a caretaker | High: staff, food, residents every day | Low: the operator runs it |
| Gross | A monthly rent per flat | Rent per bed times beds; more if full | A fixed lease or a share of revenue |
| Rules | Tenancy law, society rules | Licences, police reporting, fire, FSSAI, GST | The operator runs the PG, you are the landlord |
| Risk | Vacancy between tenants | Occupancy, staff, enforcement | The operator's solvency and a lock-in |
| Cash | Stable | Swings with occupancy | Fixed if a lease |
What does the PG actually earn on an owned building?
On an owned 50-bed building with meals and six hired staff, our model gives ₹1,02,774 a month at 85% occupancy (24.9% of revenue), before the owner's own pay and any loan at 85% occupancy, before the owner's own pay and any loan. At 70% the same building earns ₹45,795 less a month at any lease (7.5 beds) less. A 10-bed owned house with two hired staff loses money; with family labour, it gives the family ₹32,689 at 85% occupancy, which is the family's labour paid to itself, not profit. See what a PG looks like with hired staff.
To compare, collect two or three quotes for what each flat in your building would rent for and subtract the extra costs of letting (a caretaker, repairs, vacancy). Compare that with the PG result at 70% occupancy, after paying a manager. If the PG's advantage disappears at 70%, flats are the safer choice.
What about leasing the building to an operator?
Operators claim to pass a large share of revenue to the landlord: 55 to 60 percent of revenue to the landlord; operator margin about 15 to 20 percent (a master-lease operator's founder, August 2025). Those are an operator's own claims, and a lease locks you in: some operators have cut staff or exited the business: one operator cut about 70 percent of its staff (2019); another exited its co-living line. A worked comparison on the 50-bed building: 55 to 60 percent of 85% revenue of ₹4,85,000 is ₹2,26,738 to ₹2,47,350 a month, far above the 10 to 40 percent rent uplift claims that would give about ₹1.1 to ₹1.4 lakh on a ₹1 lakh plain rent. See lease the building out or run it yourself.
What should I check before converting?
General information, not financial advice. We found no sourced flat rents to compare against; use your own quotes.
What usually goes wrong?
- Comparing a PG at full occupancy with flats at 11 months a year.
- Forgetting that a PG costs you your time.
- Converting a residential building without sanction and then being served a notice.
- Leasing to an operator with no break clause.
Questions people ask
Do PGs earn more than flats?
They gross more per square foot, but net less once staff, food, power, vacancy and compliance are counted. The comparison turns on your own numbers.
Can I convert later if the PG does not work?
Often, but it costs fit-out and time, and residents must be given notice. See closing a PG.
Is a lease to an operator safer?
It removes the daily work but adds counterparty risk. Read the terms: lease terms for a co-living operator.
Do flats need police verification?
Tenants should be verified under local orders. See police reporting for the general rule.
These are ballpark figures to plan with, not a forecast for your business. Your own quotes and numbers come first.
Where these numbers come from
- Result of the same 50-bed PG when the owner owns the building (no lease): ₹1,02,774 a month at 85% occupancy (24.9% of revenue), before the owner's own pay and any loan (50-bed model with meals, no lease, wages at Delhi's official floors). Ballpark 42.5 x 6106 - 156731 = 102774; revenue at 85% = ₹4,12,250.
- What 70% occupancy instead of 85% does to the 50-bed leased PG: ₹45,795 less a month at any lease (7.5 beds) (50-bed leased model with meals). Ballpark 7.5 beds x 6106 = 45795.
- Monthly result of the 10-bed owned house when the family cooks and cleans: ₹32,689 at 85% occupancy, which is the family's labour paid to itself, not profit (10-bed owned house model). Ballpark Fixed falls to ₹7,550 (no cook, no housekeeper): 8.5 x 4734 - 7550 = 32689.
- Co-living operators that failed or retreated: one cut about 70 percent of its staff, another exited its co-living line: one operator cut about 70 percent of its staff (2019); another exited its co-living line (India). Reported: Outlook Business, Co-living operators that failed or retreated: one cut about 70 percent of its staff, another exited its co-living line, checked 14 November 2026.
- What a co-living operator's claimed revenue share would be on the 50-bed building: 55 to 60 percent of 85% revenue of ₹4,85,000 is ₹2,26,738 to ₹2,47,350 a month, far above the 10 to 40 percent rent uplift claims that would give about ₹1.1 to ₹1.4 lakh on a ₹1 lakh plain rent (50-bed building, owner compared with leasing to an operator). Ballpark 0.55 x 412250 = 226738; 0.60 x 412250 = 247350. The claims are operator statements and do not agree; no signed deal, owner interview or default case was found. Ask for three operator quotes.
- Minimum area per occupant, Bengaluru PG licensing: 70 sq ft per occupant (Bengaluru). Official source: Karnataka High Court order, Princess Ladies PG v Chief Commissioner (10 Sep 2026), Minimum area per occupant, Bengaluru PG licensing, checked 14 November 2026.
Fees, rates and rents change. Check the official source before you pay or sign anything.
Money and tax · PG or paying guest accommodation
More on money and tax for a pg or paying guest accommodation
26 pages on this. You are on number 19.
- I took a loan for a PG building that is not filling. What are my options?
- What does a PG look like on paper once I pay a hired warden, cook and guard?
- I own a building. Is a PG better than renting it out as flats?
- My PG is running out of cash. What are my options?
- What happens to my PG's numbers if occupancy falls by 30 to 50 percent?
- What does food cost per resident per month, and what meal price covers it?
- How much cash should I keep after opening a PG, and can I use residents' deposits?
- How do I fund a PG: savings, a loan, a partner or an investor?
Reading about it is one thing; doing it in your pg or paying guest accommodation is another. If you'd like a hand working out your own numbers, tell us where you are and a person will reply, free.
Get help with this ↓What now?
Where are you?
One tap, and we point you to the right next step.