Read first
What do I do in the first 24 hours?
A relative shouting in the waiting room, a call from a lawyer, a message that someone has gone to the police: the first reaction is often to defend. The better first reaction is to protect the record and the relationship.
- Secure the original record. Put the OPD card, prescriptions, referral letter, consent forms, bills, messages and any images in a folder. Make a copy. Do not alter, add to or backdate anything. A late note is fine only if it is clearly marked with the date and time it was written.
- Write your own account the same day, privately, with times and what was said. It helps your lawyer and your memory, and it is not for the family.
- Tell your indemnity insurer immediately. Read your policy for the notice period; a late notice can cost you cover. Indemnity is not a legal requirement, but a society scheme for a physician was reported at about ₹1,675 per year a year for Rs 50 lakh cover, and Rs 1 crore at ₹3,150 per year, including GST. It is the cheapest line in the budget until the day it is the only one that matters.
- Speak to the family, kindly and factually. Say what happened, what you did and what you will do next. Do not blame the patient, the nurse or a colleague, and do not say it was your fault in a rush of feeling; ask your lawyer first about a written apology.
- Do not talk to the press or post online. Anything you write about a patient also risks breaching confidentiality (IMC 2002 clause 7.14).
No law requires a doctor to hold professional indemnity insurance, but chamber hosts and hospitals often ask for it.
What must I give the family?
The medical council code says that if a request for medical records is made by the patient, an authorised attendant or legal authorities, it should be acknowledged and the documents issued within 72 hours (IMC 2002 clause 1.3.2). Failing to maintain records for three years of indoor patients, or to provide them within 72 hours of a request, is listed in the code as professional misconduct (clause 7.2). For outpatients the code's period is less clear, and the central standard for clinics in registered states says 3 to 5 years; keep them at least three years, and longer if a dispute is open.
Records requested by a patient or an authorised person must be issued within 72 hours.
Give a complete copy and keep the original. Obtain a signature acknowledging receipt. If the request comes from a lawyer or a court, route it through your own lawyer, but do not delay past the period.
Where can a complaint go?
A patient or family usually has several routes, and they can be used together. We name them as general information; the procedures and time limits differ and are for your lawyer to explain.
| Route | What it looks at | What to prepare |
|---|---|---|
| A complaint to the State Medical Council | Professional conduct: negligence, ethics, records, advertising | Your registration, the record, your reply with the facts; the code's clauses on conduct |
| A consumer complaint | Deficiency in service and compensation | The bill, the record, your indemnity policy and your lawyer |
| A civil suit | Damages for negligence | As above; your insurer usually controls the defence |
| A criminal complaint or police case | Whether negligence was gross enough to be an offence | Your lawyer; the Supreme Court's guidelines below |
| A complaint to the clinical establishment authority or the health department | Registration conditions and standards | Registration, waste papers, the central standard's requirements |
Respond in writing, within the time stated, through your lawyer, and never ignore a notice. An ignored notice is the most common way a defensible case becomes a hard one.
What has the Supreme Court said about negligence and arrest?
In Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab (decided 5 August 2005) the Supreme Court said that a simple lack of care, an error of judgment or an accident is not proof of negligence on the part of a medical professional. So long as a doctor follows a practice acceptable to the medical profession of that day, he cannot be held liable merely because a better alternative was available. A professional may be held liable on one of two findings: he did not have the skill he claimed, or he did not exercise with reasonable competence the skill he had. The Court held that the Bolam test applies in India.
On criminal cases, the Court held that for negligence to be an offence it must be gross or of a very high degree, and that a private complaint should not be entertained unless it produces prima facie evidence in the form of a credible opinion given by another competent doctor. The investigating officer should obtain an independent and competent medical opinion, preferably from a government doctor in that branch, before proceeding against the doctor, and a doctor accused of rashness or negligence should not be arrested in a routine manner. The Court noted that the criminal process subjects a doctor to serious embarrassment and warned against complaints used as pressure to extract compensation.
Supreme Court of India, Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab, 5 Aug 2005, read on Indian Kanoon on 14 Nov 2026.
The 2005 judgment spoke of the criminal negligence provision then in the Indian Penal Code. Criminal law has since been reorganised, so ask your lawyer which section applies now and whether later decisions have changed the position. These principles help you and your lawyer, they do not decide your case.
What should my records already show?
- A dated, legible OPD card for each visit, with vitals, history, findings, diagnosis and advice, signed.
- Prescriptions with your registration number and generic names, and a note if you dispensed (IMC 2002 clauses 1.4.1, 1.5 and 3.7.1).
- Consent for procedures, in the patient's language, signed, with the risks discussed noted.
- A referral letter and an emergency record with times, if it was an emergency. See when and how to refer and what to do when a patient collapses.
- Bills and receipts, which show the visit happened and what was charged.
- Messages and call logs with the patient, which a court may ask for.
What usually goes wrong
- Adding to or rewriting the record after the event, which turns a defensible case into a damaging one.
- No indemnity, or a policy whose notice period was missed.
- A written 'sorry' or an admission written in anger and sent to the family.
- Ignoring a notice, or answering without a lawyer.
- Trying to settle privately, by cash, with no record or release.
- Posting a rebuttal online, which breaches confidentiality.
General information, not legal advice. Take a lawyer who handles medical cases as soon as a notice or a police call arrives.
Apply it to your own clinic
Do three things before anything goes wrong: take indemnity and keep the policy where you can find it; make sure every record is signed, dated and complete; and keep a lawyer's number. If a family is already angry, see angry relatives after a bad result. Tell us where you are and we can point you to the right next step; we cannot give legal advice.
Questions people ask
Do I need professional indemnity insurance?
No law requires it, but hosts and hospitals often ask for it and it pays for your defence. In one survey of early-career psychiatrists, only 36% held it. Buy it before you see your first patient.
Can I be arrested for a bad outcome?
In criminal negligence cases the Supreme Court said a doctor should not be arrested in a routine manner, and that an independent medical opinion should be taken first. Arrest remains possible where the investigation needs it, so involve your lawyer at once.
Do I have to give records if the family is angry?
Yes. The code asks for records within 72 hours of a request by the patient or an authorised person. Give a full copy, keep the original and ask for a signed receipt.
Where these numbers come from
- No law requires a doctor to hold professional indemnity insurance, but chamber hosts and hospitals often ask for it: not mandatory (India). Reported: Nidaan chamber-hire terms and indemnity providers' pages, as read in the research file, checked 14 November 2026.
- Records requested by a patient or authorised person must be issued within (IMC 2002 cl 1.3.2): 72 hours (India). Official source: Indian Medical Council (Professional Conduct, Etiquette and Ethics) Regulations 2002, nmc.org.in (opened and clause numbers checked), checked 14 November 2026.
- Supreme Court on medical negligence: an error of judgment or an accident is not negligence; Bolam test applies; criminal negligence must be gross; a private complaint needs a credible opinion of another competent doctor; the police should get an independent medical opinion; no routine arrest of an accused doctor: Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab, 5 Aug 2005 (India, doctors; the criminal provision named in the judgment has since been reorganised, so check the current section). Reported: Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab, Supreme Court of India, 5 August 2005 (Indian Kanoon copy), checked 14 November 2026.
- Professional indemnity for a physician through a society scheme, Rs 50 lakh cover, a year including 18% GST: ₹1,675 per year (India). Reported: Indian Medical Association-linked scheme rates for physicians (as read in the research file), checked 13 November 2026.
- Professional indemnity for a physician, Rs 1 crore cover, a year including 18% GST: ₹3,150 per year (India). Reported: Indian Medical Association-linked scheme rates for physicians (as read in the research file), checked 13 November 2026.
- Clinical establishment standard for a clinic: keep records at least 3 to 5 years: 3 to 5 years (central-Act states). Official source: MoHFW Clinical Establishments portal, minimum standards for clinics, checked 13 November 2026.
- Early-career psychiatrists in private practice who had professional indemnity insurance, in a survey of 100: only 36% held it (India, 100 psychiatrists; one speciality). Reported: Starting Solo: early-career psychiatrists in private practice in India, Cureus, 30 July 2025, checked 14 November 2026.
Fees, rates and rents change. Check the official source before you pay or sign anything.
Operations · Doctor's clinic
More on operations for a doctor's clinic
20 pages on this. You are on number 14.
- A patient's relatives got angry after a bad result. How do I protect myself and the clinic?
- I work 12 to 15 hours a day in my own clinic. How do solo doctors avoid burning out?
- A bad outcome at my clinic has become a legal matter. What should a doctor do?
- Everything depends on me. What happens when I am ill, and how do I reduce the risk?
- What should a doctor's clinic have ready in the two weeks before opening?
- The biomedical waste van did not come to my clinic. What do I do?
- How do I write SOPs for a clinic: desk, nursing, waste and emergencies?
- Should a doctor do home visits, and how do I charge and stay safe?
Reading about it is one thing; doing it in your doctor's clinic is another. If you'd like a hand running it smoothly day to day, tell us where you are and a person will reply, free.
Get help with this ↓What now?
Where are you?
One tap, and we point you to the right next step.