Doctor's clinic · 5 min read

A patient's relatives got angry after a bad result. How do I protect myself and the clinic?

The short answer

Prevent most of it by telling the family the truth early and plainly, so that a bad result is not also a surprise, and by having a layout, a staff routine and a phone number ready for the day it turns hostile. In an Indian survey of 617 doctors, 77.3% reported workplace violence, relatives were the perpetrators in most incidents and the patient not improving or getting worse was the top cause. If it happens: keep calm, give space, call for help early, never confront alone, and afterwards secure the record, tell your insurer and take advice.

Not sure about your case? Ask an expert, free ↓

How common is it, and why does it happen?

77.3 %Share of surveyed doctors who reported workplace violence in an Indian online survey (477 of 617, 2019-2020)

From a PLOS One survey of 617 doctors in India, 2019 to 2020: 477 reported workplace violence.

India, convenience sample · Source

In that survey relatives were the perpetrators in 82.2% of incidents and non-improvement or deterioration of the patient was the top cause. It matches what doctors say: a bad outcome plus a feeling of not being told, not being heard or being overcharged is what lights it. A Mumbai homeopath wrote that a patient told him to become a teacher if he wanted a holiday; a Chennai psychiatrist, that patients take you for granted. Most of the time it stays shouting. Sometimes it does not.

How do I make it less likely?

  • Say it early. The code says a physician should neither exaggerate nor minimise the gravity of a patient's condition and should ensure the patient or relatives know enough to serve the patient's interest (IMC 2002 clause 2.3). A relative who heard on day one that the outlook was uncertain is less angry on day five.
  • Tell the family one thing, from one person. Different words from the doctor, the nurse and the receptionist are what cause 'you people are hiding something'.
  • Announce the fee before the service and give a receipt (clause 1.8). Disputes about money are the second trigger after the outcome.
  • Get consent for anything beyond a routine consultation, in plain language, and note it. See the records page.
  • Keep the wait short and explain delays. Doctors report that a long wait is the commonest patient complaint, and it makes every later problem worse.
  • Refer early and with a letter. See when and how to refer.
  • Do not promise a cure or a day count. See what to say when patients want a guarantee.

How do I set up the clinic for the bad day?

  • Layout: the doctor's chair nearest the exit, a desk between you and the door, nothing heavy within reach, a second way out and a place for the family to wait that is not the consulting room.
  • No large cash on the desk. Use UPI and a drawer.
  • Staff: a rule that no one faces an angry relative alone, and one person whose job in a crisis is to call for help.
  • Phone: the local police control number and a neighbour or colleague who will come, saved on the desk phone. In an emergency, call the police first, not after.
  • CCTV at the entrance and the desk, if your premises allow it. It deters and it records. Check that patient privacy is respected and that you keep it only as long as you need.
  • A written notice that abuse of staff will lead to a complaint; it should be calm, not a threat.

What do I do when it is happening?

  • Stay calm and low. Lower your voice, sit or stand level, keep your hands visible, do not argue about the clinical facts in the heat.
  • Acknowledge the person. 'I can see how upset you are, and I want to tell you what happened.' Then offer a time and a place to talk, with the senior person.
  • Do not blame the nurse, the patient or another doctor. The code asks that no remark be made that impairs confidence in a colleague (clause 4.2).
  • Give space. Step back; let them leave. Do not block the door.
  • If anyone threatens or touches you or the staff, call the police and ask a colleague to witness. Your safety and your staff's come first, and a case you did not fight in the corridor is a case you can still defend.
  • If the patient is still in the clinic and needs care, carry on with the care. See what to do when a patient collapses.

What do I do afterwards?

  • Write your account the same day, with times, names and what was said. Save any CCTV for the period.
  • Secure the complete record and do not alter it. If the family asks for records, give a copy within 72 hours.
  • Tell your indemnity insurer. Take a lawyer if a complaint or notice follows. See what to do when a bad outcome becomes a legal matter.
  • If you were assaulted or threatened, file a police complaint and keep a copy. Several states have specific laws on violence against medical professionals; ask your state medical association which applies.
  • Look after the staff. A shaken receptionist who is not talked to leaves in a month. See keeping a front-desk person.
  • Review: what could have been said earlier, or done differently, and what the clinic should change.

General information, not legal or safety advice. If you are in danger, call the police.

What usually goes wrong

  • The first the family hears of the problem is the bad news.
  • Different people tell different stories.
  • The doctor argues the case in the waiting room.
  • The receptionist is left alone to face the family.
  • The record is 'tidied' afterwards.

Apply it to your own clinic

Stand where a patient's relative would stand and look at where you would go. Move one thing. Write the police number and one neighbour's number on the desk. Agree with your assistant who calls whom. Tell us about your layout and we will help you think it through.

Questions people ask

Should I apologise?

Express sympathy and explain what you know. Whether and how to apologise in writing is a question for your lawyer, because a written admission can be used against you.

Can I refuse to treat the relatives later?

You are free to choose whom you serve, except in an emergency (IMC 2002 clause 2.4), and you should not withdraw from a case without adequate notice. Ask your lawyer before ending care.

Is CCTV allowed in a clinic?

At the entrance and the desk, generally yes. In a consulting room it intrudes on patient privacy; avoid it unless you have explicit consent.

Where these numbers come from

  1. Share of surveyed doctors who reported workplace violence in an Indian online survey (477 of 617, 2019-2020): 77.3 % (India, convenience sample). Reported: PLOS ONE, Violence against doctors in India (online survey, Nov 2019 to Apr 2020), checked 13 November 2026.
  2. Share of workplace-violence incidents in which relatives of the patient were the perpetrators, in an Indian online survey of doctors (2019 to 2020): 82.2% (India, 617 doctors, online survey). Reported: Workplace violence against doctors in India, PLOS One, 18 September 2020, checked 14 November 2026.

Fees, rates and rents change. Check the official source before you pay or sign anything.

Operations · Doctor's clinic

More on operations for a doctor's clinic

20 pages on this. You are on number 12.

  1. What must a teleconsult prescription contain, and what records do I keep?
  2. When and how should a doctor refer a patient, and what goes in the referral letter?
  3. A patient's relatives got angry after a bad result. How do I protect myself and the clinic?
  4. I work 12 to 15 hours a day in my own clinic. How do solo doctors avoid burning out?
  5. A bad outcome at my clinic has become a legal matter. What should a doctor do?
  6. Everything depends on me. What happens when I am ill, and how do I reduce the risk?
  7. What should a doctor's clinic have ready in the two weeks before opening?
  8. The biomedical waste van did not come to my clinic. What do I do?
All 20 on operations →

Reading about it is one thing; doing it in your doctor's clinic is another. If you'd like a hand running it smoothly day to day, tell us where you are and a person will reply, free.

Get help with this ↓

What now?

Next question · 5 of 6 in Who comes, how they choose and why they returnA patient left a one-star Google review about the wait. Can a doctor reply, and can I sue? →

Where are you?

One tap, and we point you to the right next step.

Menu

Read

Ask an expert Ask an expertFree, real peopleHub
Ask an expert