Doctor's clinic · 5 min read

A patient left a one-star Google review about the wait. Can a doctor reply, and can I sue?

The short answer

You can reply, briefly and without confirming the person was your patient, mentioning no diagnosis, treatment, visit or bill. Your medical-ethics duty of confidentiality and the data-protection law both apply to public replies. You cannot get Google to remove a genuine review because you dispute it, and a legal notice often backfires when sent to a real patient over an opinion. The better use of an evening is to fix the cause: three complaints (the wait, billing surprises and the desk's manner) recur on clinic pages, according to reputation consultancies.

Not sure about your case? Ask an expert, free ↓

Eleven pm, the phone lights up

You see a new one-star review: "Waited two hours, doctor rushed, receptionist rude." Your hands are warm. You know the person: it was the busy Saturday when the power went and the queue doubled. You want to write what happened. You cannot, and the reasons are both ethical and legal.

What you cannot do in a reply

  • Confirm the person was a patient. Even "we are sorry about your visit on Saturday" tells strangers they were.
  • Mention diagnosis, treatment, a bill or the date. The 2002 ethics regulations ask the doctor not to disclose a patient's secrets (clause 7.14) except in a few listed cases, and the Digital Personal Data Protection Act 2023 and its 2025 Rules treat a patient's health data as personal data; the main duties apply from 13 May 2027.
  • Argue with the facts. The audience is the next patient reading the page, not the writer.
  • Offer anything for taking it down. The NMC advertising guidelines of 6 October 2026 bar manipulating reviews and ratings (clause 8.1(xii)).
  • Ask patients for good reviews to bury it. See the next section.

What the 6 October 2026 guidelines say about reviews

Clause 3.2, Explanation V reads, in part: "An RMP shall not request or share patient testimonials, recommendations, endorsements or reviews for professional promotion on social media." It also bars soliciting, buying, procuring or manipulating fake, paid or misleading reviews and ratings. The text does not mention replying to a review, and it does not say whether a neutral "leave us feedback" card at the desk counts as a request. Commentators disagree. The cautious reading, which we recommend until a council clarifies: do not request reviews, offer nothing for them, and do not repost them. Replying politely and generally is not a request or a share.

The penalty ladder runs from a warning and mandatory ethics training for a first violation to removal from the register for one to three years for repeats, at the State Medical Council's discretion, after a show-cause notice (clause 10).

A reply that works (consultancy advice, not a rule)

Three reputation consultancies, writing between July and August 2026, give the same outline. It is advice from vendors, not a council ruling.

  • Acknowledge the feeling, not the facts. "We are sorry to read this. Waiting is frustrating and we want to hear more."
  • Offer a named person and a number, and sign as the clinic, not the treating doctor.
  • Reply within 24 to 72 hours. Draft it cold, the next morning, not at eleven at night.
  • If you think it is fake (a competitor, a non-patient), say you could not find a matching record, and report the review to Google with screenshots and timestamps.

Can I sue?

Google does not remove a genuine negative review because the clinic disputes it. A review that makes a false statement of fact (not an opinion) may be defamation, and a legal notice through counsel is reported to cost about Rs 15,000 to 40,000, according to one reputation consultancy. Sent to a real patient over an opinion about waiting time, it often backfires: it becomes a story, usually a worse one. Talk to a lawyer before you send anything, and talk to your indemnity insurer if the review alleges harm. This is general information, not legal advice.

Fix the cause

Reputation consultancies say the same three complaints recur on clinic pages: the wait, a billing surprise and the desk's manner. They are cheaper to fix than to explain.

  • Tell people about delays. A WhatsApp message with a live estimate, or a sign with the current wait.
  • Put fees on the board and say them at the desk. The 2002 regulations ask the doctor to display fees on the chamber board (clause 3.7.1).
  • Train the desk on one script for lateness and for emergencies.
  • Close the loop privately. A patient who writes a bad review often wants a call; offer one in your reply and keep that call out of the public page.

If you are small, in a polyclinic or a hospital's chamber

A one-doctor clinic answers personally and slowly, which is fine. A polyclinic should have one person answer for all rooms, so no consultant replies to a review about another's patient. A visiting consultant in someone else's room does not control the listing; ask the host who answers for the practice's page, and say so in the room agreement.

What usually goes wrong

  • Replying at night in anger, naming the date and the problem, and then needing a lawyer.
  • Confirming the person was a patient by the wording of the apology.
  • Asking staff and relatives to post five-star reviews, which the guidelines bar and which readers can spot.
  • Ignoring every review, good and bad, so the page looks abandoned.
  • Sending a legal notice to a patient whose only offence was waiting.

Apply it to your clinic

If a review makes a serious allegation, do not reply alone: call your indemnity insurer. If the page is mostly about getting found rather than being criticised, see the Google profile page.

Questions people ask

Can I ask patients to leave a review?

The NMC guidelines of 6 October 2026 say a doctor shall not request or share patient reviews for promotion on social media. Whether a neutral feedback card counts is not settled; the cautious course is not to ask.

Can Google remove a review I do not like?

Only if it breaks Google's rules, such as a fake review or one from a non-patient. A genuine negative review stays even if you dispute it.

Is replying to a review allowed under the guidelines?

The text does not address replies. Keep it short, general and free of any patient detail, so it cannot be read as a testimonial or a disclosure.

Customers and marketing · Doctor's clinic

More on customers and marketing for a doctor's clinic

24 pages on this. You are on number 17.

  1. Other doctors will not refer to me unless I pay. How do specialists get referrals honestly?
  2. How do I tie up with housing societies, schools and small companies for health checks?
  3. A patient left a one-star Google review about the wait. Can a doctor reply, and can I sue?
  4. How can a small clinic compete with a corporate hospital's advertising and OPD?
  5. Patients expect a medicine for everything. Can I prescribe less and still keep my clinic busy?
  6. Should I ask senior doctors, chemists and labs near me for referrals, and how?
  7. How does a doctor use Instagram and reels without breaking the NMC rules?
  8. Patients call me at night and on holidays. How do I set limits?
All 24 on customers and marketing →

Reading about it is one thing; doing it in your doctor's clinic is another. If you'd like a hand bringing in customers, tell us where you are and a person will reply, free.

Get help with this ↓

What now?

You finished the chapterBack to Who comes, how they choose and why they return →

Where are you?

One tap, and we point you to the right next step.

Menu

Read

Ask an expert Ask an expertFree, real peopleHub
Ask an expert