D2C brand · Chapter · 13 questions

Margins, CAC and break-even

What does one order earn, what does it cost to win a customer, and how many orders break even?

Most D2C brands that struggle are not short of orders; they are short of margin on each one. This chapter builds the order's profit and loss from the top: what one order keeps after goods, shipping both ways, fees and returns, what the ad that won it costs, and how many such orders a month cover fixed costs. It then turns to the two numbers every founder is told to watch, break-even ROAS and CAC, and to the harder questions of how much of revenue should go to ads, whether to lose money on a first order, and what gross margin a brand needs. The general method for any product brand sits in the included pages on landed cost, markup, contribution margin and returns; the pages here apply it to a D2C brand with COD, ads and repeat. Worked examples use assumed inputs, shown on the page, so you can rerun them with yours. Pricing and discount pages are in the range and pricing chapter.

Useful when you want to: start one · run it day to day · fix profit or cash problems

  1. 01D2C brandWhat does one D2C order's profit and loss look like, line by line?Take every rupee that comes in with an order and every rupee that goes out because of it, averaged over all orders placed, not just those delivered. In our worked example, a ₹799 personal-care product keeps about ₹236 after goods, shipping and fees, but about ₹250 of ads wins the order, so it loses roughly ₹14 on every order paid for. A ₹2,499 apparel product keeps about ₹761 before ads and about ₹311 after ₹450 of ads. Every input is an assumption, so rerun it with yours.
  2. 02D2C brandHow many orders a month does a ₹799 or a ₹2,499 D2C brand need to break even?Break-even orders a month equal your monthly fixed costs divided by the contribution each order keeps after goods, shipping, returns, fees and ads. In our worked examples, a ₹799 personal-care brand needs about 988 orders a month if 30% of orders are repeat or organic, and never breaks even if every order is paid for. A ₹2,499 apparel brand needs about 257 orders a month if every order is paid, or 189 if a quarter are repeat or organic. All inputs are assumptions.
  3. 03D2C brandWhat ROAS do I need to break even on my D2C brand's ads?Break-even ROAS is the order value divided by what the order keeps before ads. In our worked examples, a ₹799 product that keeps about ₹236 before ads needs a ROAS of about 3.4 just to cover the ad, and a ₹2,499 product that keeps about ₹761 needs about 3.3. That is the ROAS at which an order pays for its own customer; fixed costs need more. Platform dashboards usually overstate ROAS because they count orders that later fail or come back.
  4. 04D2C brandWhat is a good customer acquisition cost for my D2C brand's category?There is no sourced CAC for a single category in India, and the figures that circulate are vendor or survey data. One 35-brand scan puts the blended average at ₹800–1,200 per new customer, direction only. A good CAC for you is one your product can pay: below what the first order keeps before ads, or recovered from repeat orders within the time you can fund.
  5. 05D2C brandHow much of a D2C brand's revenue should go to ads?Reported marketing spend for listed or filing Indian D2C brands runs from about 8% to over 55% of revenue, with early and fast-growing brands at 30 to 60% and mature brands that lean on repeat and offline at about 8 to 30%. A new bootstrapped brand should plan for the high end until repeat is proven. A better rule than a percentage is to set the budget from what an order keeps before ads: spend only while each order, or each customer over a payback window you can fund, keeps more than it costs.
  6. 06D2C brandIs it okay to lose money on the first order to win a repeat customer?It is okay only if three things are true: repeat is real and measured, the repeat orders earn enough to pay back the first loss, and you can fund the wait. A brand whose first order loses ₹14 and whose repeat customers keep ₹236 before ads each time recovers in one repeat order. The same brand with 10% repeat does not. Reported repeat rates of 10–30% of customers of customers mean most brands cannot assume a repeat; measure yours before you plan on it.
  7. 07D2C brandWhat gross margin does a D2C brand need to survive ads and returns?An analyst's read of 34 Indian D2C brands puts the line at 60% or more; 70% or more copes best with quick commerce. That is the analyst's judgement, not a rule, but the arithmetic backs it: once returns, shipping, fees and ads are paid, a brand with a gross margin below about 50% has almost nothing left for rent, salaries and profit. Work backwards from the profit you want. If the result is higher than your product's margin, change the price, the cost or the product before you scale ads.
  8. 08D2C brandHow do I work out my D2C brand's customer lifetime value?Use contribution, not revenue, and a fixed time window. Customer lifetime value over twelve months equals the contribution from the first order plus the average number of repeat orders in those months times the contribution of a repeat order, measured on a cohort of customers who all first bought in the same month. Then compare it with CAC. A formula that multiplies average order value by an assumed lifetime overstates it for most small brands, because repeat is 10–30% of customers of customers in a survey, not 100%.
  9. 09D2C brandHow much do shipping, packaging and payment fees add to each D2C order?For a parcel of about 500 g, forward shipping is reported at ₹40–120 per order, from same-city to inter-state. Cash on delivery adds a handling fee, modelled by one courier calculator as Higher of ₹35 or 1.5% of order value. A prepaid order pays a gateway fee of 2.36% of order value. Packaging adds a few tens of rupees, and a 3PL adds ₹18–80 per order per order. All of it, plus GST on freight, can take 15 to 25% of a ₹799 order.
  10. 10Product brandsHow do I work out the landed cost of one unit, including freight, packaging and GST?Landed cost is everything you pay to get one sellable unit into your stock, divided by the units that actually arrive sellable. It starts with the maker's price and adds inbound freight, packaging, labels, testing, import duty if any, and an allowance for damage and rejects. GST you can claim as input credit is not a cost; GST you cannot claim is. Landed cost is the base for every later number, from MRP to break-even, so work it out per SKU, not as one average.
  11. 11Product brandsHow do I get from my cost to an MRP, and how much margin is left after discounts?Set the MRP by working back from where you will sell, not by multiplying your cost. Decide the price you actually want customers to pay, add the room your channels and discounts need, and check that what is left after GST, channel fees, shipping, returns and the discount still covers your landed cost with margin to spare. Markup and margin are not the same: a 100% markup on cost is a 50% margin on price. The rules on what the MRP means are in the Legal Metrology rules; read the current text before you print.
  12. 12Product brandsWhat is contribution margin per order, and how do I work it out for my brand?Contribution margin is what each order leaves after every cost that moves with that order. Work it in three steps: CM1 is net revenue minus the landed cost of the goods you actually keep sold, CM2 takes off shipping both ways, payment fees and COD charges, and CM3 takes off the ads that won the order. If CM3 is positive, each order adds to the money available for rent, salaries and tools. If it is negative, selling more makes you poorer.
  13. 13Product brandsHow much does a return or a failed delivery really cost my brand?A failed delivery (RTO) and a customer return cost different amounts, and a brand loses money on both. Reported planning figures for an RTO order run from ₹150–300 per order, made up of two shipping legs, a COD handling fee and sometimes written-off stock, before counting the ad money that won the order. A customer return adds refund handling and, if the unit cannot be resold, its full landed cost. Work out your own figure per order; a blended average hides the worst orders.

Menu

Read

Ask an expert Ask an expertFree, real peopleHub
Ask an expert