Subscription brand · Chapter · 4 questions

Retention, churn and what a subscriber is worth

When does a subscription brand earn its customer acquisition cost back?

A subscription brand is paid back over several deliveries, so what decides the result is how long customers stay. This chapter sets out the three numbers, contribution per delivery, monthly churn and CAC, with a table of churn against lifetime value, and says plainly that no Indian benchmark for subscription churn was found. It sits beside the general pages on lifetime value, first-order loss and repeat customers.

Useful when you want to: start one · run it day to day

  1. 01Subscription brandWhen does a subscription D2C brand make money: retention, LTV and churn?A subscription brand makes money when the customers it keeps pay back what it cost to win them, usually over several deliveries. The numbers that decide it are monthly churn, contribution per delivery and CAC. In our worked example, with CAC of ₹400, contribution of ₹180 per delivery and 10% monthly churn, a customer is worth about ₹1,800 over their life and the brand earns back its CAC in the third delivery. The checked research found no sourced churn rate for Indian subscription brands; one agency case reported repeat rising from 14% to 41% at 90 days, which is a vendor case.
  2. 02D2C brandHow do I work out my D2C brand's customer lifetime value?Use contribution, not revenue, and a fixed time window. Customer lifetime value over twelve months equals the contribution from the first order plus the average number of repeat orders in those months times the contribution of a repeat order, measured on a cohort of customers who all first bought in the same month. Then compare it with CAC. A formula that multiplies average order value by an assumed lifetime overstates it for most small brands, because repeat is 10–30% of customers of customers in a survey, not 100%.
  3. 03D2C brandIs it okay to lose money on the first order to win a repeat customer?It is okay only if three things are true: repeat is real and measured, the repeat orders earn enough to pay back the first loss, and you can fund the wait. A brand whose first order loses ₹14 and whose repeat customers keep ₹236 before ads each time recovers in one repeat order. The same brand with 10% repeat does not. Reported repeat rates of 10–30% of customers of customers mean most brands cannot assume a repeat; measure yours before you plan on it.
  4. 04D2C brandHow do I get repeat customers without more discounts?Customers come back when the product runs out, a reminder arrives at that moment, reordering is easy and they trust you. Most of that costs less than a discount. Time a message to the day a pack ends, sell a refill or a related second product, make the reorder one tap, answer complaints like a person and keep the product consistent. Use a discount only as a targeted offer to lapsed buyers, and work out what it costs before you send it.

Menu

Read

Ask an expert Ask an expertFree, real peopleHub
Ask an expert