Read first
The third box is where the money starts
A subscription brand sells the same thing every month: a refill, a consumable or a box. The first delivery is usually a loss, because the ad that won the customer costs more than that box keeps. The second and third are where it is paid back, if the customer is still there. That shifts the question from what an order earns to how long a customer stays. The research for this lane was thin: subscription and offline distribution economics were flagged as not researched, so this page gives the method, a clearly marked example and what to measure.
The three numbers
| Number | How to work it out | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Contribution per delivery | Net price minus landed cost, shipping, payment fee, returns; no ads; see contribution margin | What each box keeps |
| Monthly churn | Share of active subscribers who stop in a month | How long a customer stays: average life in months is about 1 divided by churn |
| CAC | Ads and creator cost per new subscriber; see good CAC | What it costs to win one |
| Lifetime value in contribution | Contribution per delivery times average number of deliveries | What a subscriber is worth to you |
| Payback in deliveries | CAC divided by contribution per delivery | How many boxes before the ad is repaid |
A worked example
Our example, not a real brand. A refill brand keeps ₹180 per delivery, with CAC of ₹400. At 10% monthly churn, average life is about 10 months, so lifetime value is about 10 × ₹180 = ₹1,800 and the brand makes about ₹1,400 per customer after CAC. Payback takes 400 ÷ 180, about 2.2 deliveries.
| Monthly churn | Average life | Lifetime contribution | After CAC of ₹400 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5% | about 20 months | ₹3,600 | ₹3,200 |
| 10% | about 10 months | ₹1,800 | ₹1,400 |
| 20% | about 5 months | ₹900 | ₹500 |
| 30% | about 3.3 months | ₹600 | ₹200 |
| 40% | about 2.5 months | ₹450 | ₹50 |
At 40% monthly churn the brand barely recovers its CAC. That is why a subscription brand's job is retention: a small improvement in churn does more than a small cut in ad cost. A discounted first box moves payback later; see first-order loss.
What the research does say
- Subscription or refill packs are one of the ways brands raise repeat. One agency case reports repeat rising from 14% to 41% at 90 days; it is a vendor case and low confidence.
- Repeat in general is reported at 10–30% of customers of customers in a survey of founders; a subscription model targets a higher share on a schedule.
- Billing needs mandates. Recurring payments need customers to set up a mandate with their bank or card. Failed mandates are a known source of lost subscribers, but no failure rate was sourced.
- Only for products that run out. Consumables suit subscriptions; one-off items do not.
- The consumer rules still apply. Express consent, no pre-ticked boxes and a clear cancellation route; see ecommerce rules.
How to improve the economics
- Lengthen life: a reminder before each delivery, a skip or pause option and a flexible cadence.
- Cut involuntary churn: retry failed payments and ask for an updated mandate.
- Raise contribution per delivery: a bundle or a larger pack reduces shipping per rupee.
- Lower CAC: an owned channel such as WhatsApp or email brings subscribers at a lower cost; see WhatsApp and email flows.
- Measure by cohort: subscribers who joined in the same month, by how many stay each month.
If you are small, or already bigger
A starter brand should not build a subscription until a product shows repeat purchases without it; a subscription on a product people do not reorder only converts a one-off buyer into a refund request. A brand with a consumable and 90-day repeat above 20% can test a subscription on one SKU with a simple pause option. A larger brand should track churn by cohort and by reason, and fund retention before it funds acquisition.
What usually goes wrong
- Assuming churn is low because the first few weeks look good.
- A deep first-box discount with no sign the customer stays.
- Hard-to-find cancellation, which turns churn into complaints.
- Ignoring failed payments.
- Averaging cohorts from different seasons.
- Measuring revenue per subscriber, not contribution.
This page is general information, not financial advice. The example uses assumed inputs; measure your own churn and contribution.
Test your subscription
To test your numbers, tell us your product and price.
Questions people ask
What is a good churn rate?
No sourced benchmark was found for Indian subscription brands. Compare your churn with the payback in deliveries, not with a figure from another business.
Should I offer a discount on the first box?
Only if the later boxes pay it back. See first-order loss.
Do I need a mandate for recurring payments?
Recurring card or UPI payments usually need the customer to set one up with their bank or payment app. Ask your payment gateway how it handles it.
These are ballpark figures to plan with, not a forecast for your business. Your own quotes and numbers come first.
Where these numbers come from
- Repeat purchase rate reported by D2C founders: 10–30% of customers (India; survey of 100+ founders (DSG, Meta, Viralmint, December 2025)). Reported: Entrepreneur India (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.
Fees, rates and rents change. Check the official source before you pay or sign anything.
What now?
Where are you?
One tap, and we point you to the right next step.