Read first
The numbers that keep not improving
You changed the ads, the price and the packaging, and the month still ends the same way: orders up, cash down. You are tired, and each fix has taken longer than you said it would. The question is no longer what to try next. It is whether the business can work at all.
The signs below are drawn from founders' accounts, a few analyst readings and vendor data. They are patterns, not a diagnosis; no brand died of just one number. This page is general information, not advice.
Seven signs, with the test for each
| Sign | Test it | What the sources say |
|---|---|---|
| Every order loses money after returns and ads | Contribution per order on the last 90 days | A reported band is 20–35% of net revenue; below zero for months is a red flag |
| Almost nobody buys twice | Share of customers who rebuy within 90 days | Founders report 10–30% of customers; one vendor guide treats under 15% as a warning |
| Gross margin cannot carry ads and returns | Price less landed cost, as a share of price | An analyst reading of 34 brands puts 60% or more; 70% or more copes best with quick commerce; no brand under 45% reached profit at scale without a structural cost fix, in that reading |
| Cost to get a customer exceeds what a customer is worth | Marketing divided by new customers, against margin over a year | Reported CAC is ₹800–1,200 per new customer; yours may differ widely |
| Returns and RTO eat the margin | RTO and return cost per order | COD RTO is reported at 25–38% of COD orders across sources |
| Stock keeps piling up | Months of stock on hand, and what share is slow | Cash is tied in cartons |
| Runway is shorter than the next test | Cash divided by monthly loss, with dues | See the steps in the pivot page |
Two of these together deserve a hard look; four are hard to argue with.
What the failures we read had in common
- Over-expansion before the basics worked, with a loss growing faster than revenue, in the case of a brand that stopped operating after raising about ₹125 crore.
- Burning cash on discounts and influencers that did not build repeat, said one founder in hindsight.
- A commoditised category with no buyer, where one founder searched over a year for a buyer.
- A margin too low to carry the costs of ads and returns.
- One platform or channel that could switch you off or undercut you.
Many of these were in brands that had raised money. Small brands that quietly closed are almost absent from the record, so the failures we know are skewed to the ones that made news.
Signs that are not signs
- One bad month, especially after a sale or a festival, when stock and returns are lumpy.
- A falling ROAS on its own. Brands are moving to contribution margin, blended CAC, payback and repeat. A poor ad number matters only if it takes contribution below zero.
- Slow growth with healthy margin and repeat. Growth is a choice, not a duty.
- A copycat by itself. It can be handled; see marketplace copies.
A fair last test
Before you decide, run one clean test of four to six weeks. Choose the single change you believe would add most to contribution per order: price, pack, payment mix, or dropping a channel. Write down the number that would make you continue, and the number that would make you stop. Decide in advance so the result cannot be argued away.
If the test fails, pick one of three: shrink to the one line that works, sell the brand, or close it properly. Pivot or close walks through the choice, and how to sell a D2C brand and how to shut one down cover the next steps.
What usually goes wrong
- Not running the test, because it feels like admitting defeat.
- Running five changes at once, then not knowing which one mattered.
- Putting in personal savings after the numbers have said stop.
- Looking only at revenue, which can rise while cash falls.
- Delaying the CA conversation about dues until there is no cash to pay them.
Apply it to your brand
If several signs show and you would like to talk through the numbers, tell us where you are.
Questions people ask
What is the biggest sign a D2C brand is failing?
Negative contribution per order for several months, after returns and ads, with no repeat to pay back the first sale.
Is low ROAS a reason to shut down?
Not by itself. Look at contribution margin, repeat and payback; ROAS alone can mislead.
How long should I wait before closing a brand?
Until a clean test of four to six weeks has failed, and no longer than your runway allows.
Can a failing brand be sold?
Sometimes, for its name, list and stock, but one founder spent over a year looking for a buyer. We found no sourced price for small brands.
This is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Get a lawyer and a chartered accountant on any sale or closure.
Where these numbers come from
- Contribution margin band, Indian D2C: 20–35% of net revenue (India; one LinkedIn post, about 2023; base.com gives beauty 25 to 40, fashion 10 to 25). Reported: LinkedIn post by a D2C operator on returns and contribution margin (about 2023), checked 13 November 2026.
- Repeat purchase rate reported by D2C founders: 10–30% of customers (India; survey of 100+ founders (DSG, Meta, Viralmint, December 2025)). Reported: Entrepreneur India (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.
- Gross margin that lets a brand carry ads and returns: 60% or more; 70% or more copes best with quick commerce (India; analyst reading of 34 brands). Ballpark The CPG Lab Substack scan of 34 Indian D2C brands (2026) read gross margin off filings; the analyst's own judgement, not a rule.
- Blended customer acquisition cost: ₹800–1,200 per new customer (India; a 35-brand scan, direction only; one series runs ₹650 to ₹1,850 over 2021 to 25). Reported: The CPG Lab (Substack) (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.
- RTO rate on COD orders across sources: 25–38% of COD orders (all India; Razorpay 25 to 30, ClickPost 37.5, other vendors 28 to 35; vendor blogs, not audited). Reported: Razorpay blog (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.
Fees, rates and rents change. Check the official source before you pay or sign anything.
Selling and closing · D2C brand
More on selling and closing for a d2c brand
8 pages on this. You are on number 6.
- How is a D2C brand valued when it is sold?
- How do I find a buyer for my D2C brand?
- Can I sell my D2C brand to a bigger company, and what do they check?
- How do I shut down my D2C brand properly?
- Should I pivot my D2C brand or close it?
- What are the signs a D2C brand will not recover?
- What do I do with my stock and trademark when I close my D2C brand?
- How do I clear GST and pay vendors when closing my D2C brand?
Reading about it is one thing; doing it in your d2c brand is another. If you'd like a hand handing over or closing properly, tell us where you are and a person will reply, free.
Get help with this ↓What now?
Where are you?
One tap, and we point you to the right next step.
What to read next
Related questions
Where this fits in your journey
- Step 1 of 8How to shut down a D2C brand properly in India: stock, trade mark, GST and dues: Make sure closing is the right call→
- Step 9 of 9My D2C brand has sales but no profit: what to fix first, step by step: Set a date and a number, and decide→
- Step 1 of 8How to sell your D2C brand in India: value, buyers and what they check: Decide why and when to sell→