D2C brand · 4 min read

I lose money on every order. Which lever do I pull first?

The short answer

Pull the lever that moves your contribution per order most for the least damage to sales, and measure it before and after. In our worked example of a ₹799 product losing about ₹14 an order, a ₹100 price rise adds about ₹74, 30% repeat or organic orders add about ₹75, ₹50 less CAC adds ₹50, halving COD share adds about ₹28, and cutting returns from 8% to 4% adds about ₹28. Every input is an assumption, so rerun the sums with yours before you choose.

Not sure about your case? Ask an expert, free ↓

Every sale makes the hole deeper

When each order loses money, growth is the wrong goal. More orders mean more loss, and the harder you push ads the faster the cash goes. The first job is to stop the loss, and the first step is to see which lever moves your number most. The ranking below is for one worked example; yours will differ, but the method is the same: change one input at a time and see what it does to CM3 per order.

A sensitivity table for one example

Our worked example, not a real brand: a ₹799 personal-care product with GST at 5%, landed cost ₹280, packaging ₹35, forward shipping ₹55, 40% COD, 30% COD RTO, 3% prepaid RTO, 8% customer returns and CAC ₹250 per order placed. It keeps about ₹236 before ads and loses about ₹14 after them; see one order's profit and loss.

Our model, run one input at a time; the base is −₹14 per order. Reported ranges for COD RTO are 25–38% of COD orders and for forward shipping ₹40–120 per order. Assumptions, not benchmarks.
Change one thingNew CM3 per orderGain per orderWhat it costs you
Price from ₹799 to ₹899about +₹60+₹74Some orders; test before rolling out
30% of orders are repeat or organic (no ad cost)about +₹61+₹75Takes months to build; see repeat customers
CAC from ₹250 to ₹200about +₹36+₹50Creative and audience work; may not hold as spend grows
COD share from 40% to 20%about +₹14+₹28Some COD buyers will not pay online
Customer returns from 8% to 4%about +₹14+₹28Better photos, sizing, packing
Landed cost from ₹280 to ₹250about +₹12+₹26A new maker or a bigger batch
COD RTO from 30% to 20%about +₹4+₹19Order confirmation, pincode rules
Shipping from ₹55 to ₹45about −₹2+₹12Rate negotiation, lighter pack
Packaging from ₹35 to ₹25about −₹4+₹10Cheaper pack

A sensible order of attack

  1. 1. Stop the worst losses today. Pause ad sets with the worst delivered-and-kept ROAS; see break-even ROAS. Cap the discount.
  2. 2. Tackle COD. Confirm COD orders before dispatch, add a prepaid nudge and drop pincodes with high failure. Cheap, quick and the effect is immediate; see stop COD or keep it.
  3. 3. Test a price rise. The largest single effect in the table, but test on a slice of traffic first; see price your product.
  4. 4. Work on CAC. New creative, a tighter audience, a better offer and a better landing page; see good CAC.
  5. 5. Cut returns. Fix the cause: sizing, description, packaging.
  6. 6. Cut cost last. A second maker or a bigger batch takes weeks and cash.
  7. 7. Build repeat in parallel. It is the biggest lever and the slowest.

Change one thing at a time and give it a week of data. If two levers change together you will not know which worked.

When a lever is not enough

If even all of these together cannot lift CM3 above zero, the product, the price band or the channel may be wrong. A cheap product with a thin margin and a high COD share is the hardest shape in the table. Options: sell in a bundle that raises order value, move to a channel with a better fit, or stop; see fix the product or stop. Do not borrow to cover the loss; see my brand is running out of cash.

If you are small, or already bigger

A starter brand often loses money per order because the first batch is small and the first ads are untuned. Give it a defined test and a stop rule. A larger brand should run the table per channel and per top product, because the loss usually sits in a few of them and the others pay for it.

What usually goes wrong

  • Chasing volume while each order loses money.
  • Changing price, creative and COD in the same week.
  • Cutting packaging until damage rises.
  • Raising price without a test and losing half the orders.
  • Believing that more repeat will arrive on its own.
  • Looking at CM1 and calling it fine.

This page is general information, not financial advice. The ranking is for one assumed example; rerun it with your own numbers.

Run your own table

If you want a second pair of eyes on the sheet, tell us your numbers.

Questions people ask

Should I raise price or cut ads first?

Test price on a slice of traffic. Pause the worst ad sets at once, since they lose money every day.

Is COD worth keeping?

It depends on your RTO and margin. See stop COD or keep it.

How long should I test a lever?

A week of data for ads and COD changes; longer for price and repeat.

These are ballpark figures to plan with, not a forecast for your business. Your own quotes and numbers come first.

Where these numbers come from

  1. RTO rate on COD orders across sources: 25–38% of COD orders (all India; Razorpay 25 to 30, ClickPost 37.5, other vendors 28 to 35; vendor blogs, not audited). Reported: Razorpay blog (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.
  2. Forward shipping for a parcel of about 500 g: ₹40–120 per order (all India; ₹40 same city to ₹120 inter-state; special zones can be higher). Reported: Razorpay blog (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.

Fees, rates and rents change. Check the official source before you pay or sign anything.

Money and tax · D2C brand

More on money and tax for a d2c brand

33 pages on this. You are on number 14.

  1. What goes into a D2C brand's launch cost, line by line?
  2. Can I start a D2C brand with under ₹1 lakh?
  3. I lose money on every order. Which lever do I pull first?
  4. What ROAS do I need to break even on my D2C brand's ads?
  5. Which D2C numbers should I have ready before talking to an investor?
  6. Why is my D2C brand's cash always stuck, and how do I free it?
  7. How does a D2C brand handle cash swings around Diwali and wedding season?
  8. How much cash should I keep aside for the first six months of my D2C brand?
All 33 on money and tax →

Reading about it is one thing; doing it in your d2c brand is another. If you'd like a hand working out your own numbers, tell us where you are and a person will reply, free.

Get help with this ↓

What now?

Next question · 3 of 6 in When it is not workingShould I pivot my D2C brand or close it? →

Where are you?

One tap, and we point you to the right next step.

Menu

Read

Ask an expert Ask an expertFree, real peopleHub
Ask an expert