Read first
Half the orders, most of the returns
A brand notices that half its orders are COD and nearly all of its returns are COD too. The temptation is to switch COD off and sleep better. The owner of a similar brand did that for a week, saw orders fall to a third, and switched it back, having learned that her buyers in tier 2 towns did not have a card and did not trust a prepaid link from a page they had met a week earlier.
We found no named case with a rupee figure, so that second paragraph is a composite from what the published guides describe. The decision is a number, not a feeling.
The numbers: 100 COD orders against 100 prepaid orders
These are our own illustration for a ₹799 product, not benchmarks. Rerun them with your own costs. Assumptions: price ₹799 including 5% GST, so about ₹761 net; landed cost ₹280; outbound shipping ₹80; packing ₹20; ad cost ₹250 per order placed; COD fee ₹35; gateway fee 2.36% of order value of the order value, about ₹19; each returned order costs ₹250 (published range ₹150–300 per order).
| Line | 100 COD orders | 100 prepaid orders |
|---|---|---|
| RTO rate used | 30% (inside the published range) | 4% (inside the published range) |
| Orders delivered | 70 | 96 |
| Earned per delivered order | 761 - 280 - 80 - 20 - 35 = ₹346 | 761 - 280 - 80 - 20 - 19 = ₹362 |
| Total from delivered orders | 70 x 346 = ₹24,220 | 96 x 362 = ₹34,752 |
| Cost of returned orders | 30 x 250 = ₹7,500 | 4 x 250 = ₹1,000 |
| Ad cost on all orders placed | 100 x 250 = ₹25,000 | 100 x 250 = ₹25,000 |
| Result | about -₹8,280 | about +₹8,752 |
On these assumptions COD loses about ₹83 per order and prepaid earns about ₹88. COD breaks even where 346 minus (346 + 250) times the RTO rate equals ₹250, which is an RTO rate of about 16%. Published COD rates sit well above that: 25–38% of COD orders. That is why founders hear "stop COD" so often. It is also why verification, which lowers the RTO rate, can turn COD from a loss into a profit without losing the buyers.
Five middle paths, in order of effort
- Verify before dispatch. WhatsApp or call confirmation; see how to set up COD verification. A cheap way to reduce fake and impulse orders.
- Charge a COD fee to the buyer, or build a small prepaid discount. Compare it with the COD handling fee a courier charges, which one calculator models as Higher of ₹35 or 1.5% of order value.
- Take a part payment. A small online advance with the balance on delivery filters the unserious. Some checkout apps do this.
- Set rules by data. COD off, or deposit required, for the pincodes and order values where your RTO is highest. See how to cut RTO on COD.
- Reserve COD for known buyers. Allow it for repeat customers with a clean history, and ask first-time buyers in risky pincodes to prepay.
A full ban makes sense only if your data show that COD loses money across every pincode and order band even with verification, or if your margin per order is too low to carry any RTO.
How to test a change safely
- Pick one change and one group, such as COD off in your worst five pincodes, or verification on all COD orders.
- Measure for two to four weeks: orders, COD share, RTO rate, cost per delivered order and total profit.
- Compare against the same weeks before, taking festivals and ad changes into account.
- If orders fall by more than the profit you gain from fewer returns, undo the change.
- Keep the rule that wins and move to the next lever.
Do not judge a change on RTO alone. A lower RTO with half the orders can earn less. Judge on profit per 100 visitors.
How it differs by type of brand
- Instagram and WhatsApp-led brands take most orders as COD and have the most to lose from a ban; confirm by message and offer a prepaid discount first. See COD-first economics.
- Own-website brands can set a COD fee, a part-payment or a pincode rule at checkout, and measure the effect on conversion.
- Marketplace-first brands usually do not set COD rules: the platform decides what buyers can pay, and returns follow its policy.
- Quick-commerce brands are not exposed to COD at all, since the app takes the payment.
- Subscription brands usually avoid COD, because a recurring order needs a payment mandate.
What usually goes wrong
- Banning COD in a week of poor sales and blaming COD for what was a bad ad week.
- Offering a prepaid discount larger than the cost it saves.
- Not telling COD buyers about verification, so they feel accused.
- Ignoring that tier 2 and 3 buyers often prefer COD; the published RTO figures are also higher in those towns.
- Comparing COD and prepaid on RTO only, not on profit.
Apply it to your brand
Replace the assumptions with your price, landed cost, shipping and ad cost and your last month's COD and prepaid RTO. Work out your break-even RTO for COD. If your actual rate is above it, start with verification. Tell us where you are if you want the sheet checked. The breakdown of published RTO figures is on the RTO benchmarks reference; the general explanation is in what a normal RTO rate is.
Questions people ask
Should a new D2C brand offer COD?
Most brands that sell to tier 2 and 3 buyers need it. Start with verification and a clear policy rather than a ban, and measure COD and prepaid separately from day one.
Can I charge extra for COD?
Yes, if you show the fee clearly before the buyer pays. Marketplaces set their own rules for listings on them.
How much COD is normal?
Vendor estimates put COD at 50 to 65% of D2C orders, higher in smaller towns. No audited national figure exists.
Where these numbers come from
- RTO rate on COD orders across sources: 25–38% of COD orders (all India; Razorpay 25 to 30, ClickPost 37.5, other vendors 28 to 35; vendor blogs, not audited). Reported: Razorpay blog (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.
- Payment gateway fee on cards, UPI and netbanking: 2.36% of order value (all India; 2% plus 18% GST on the fee; one gateway's published rate). Reported: Razorpay blog (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.
- What one RTO order costs: ₹150–300 per order (all India; Razorpay buffer figure; ClickPost models ₹350 on a ₹1,200 order (range ₹285 to 490)). Reported: ClickPost (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.
- COD handling fee as modelled by one courier calculator: Higher of ₹35 or 1.5% of order value (all India; a calculator assumption, not a tariff; other sources give ₹25 to ₹50 or 1.5 to 2.5%). Reported: ClickPost (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.
Fees, rates and rents change. Check the official source before you pay or sign anything.
Operations · D2C brand
More on operations for a d2c brand
23 pages on this. You are on number 2.
- How many days of stock should a D2C brand keep?
- Should my D2C brand stop offering cash on delivery?
- How do I block fake and prank COD orders on my D2C store?
- How does a D2C brand avoid running out of stock before a festive sale?
- Should my D2C brand start with a white-label product or a custom one?
- How do I set up COD verification by OTP or WhatsApp for my D2C store?
- How should a D2C brand handle shelf life and expiry dates on its products?
- A customer says the parcel did not arrive. How should my D2C brand respond?
Reading about it is one thing; doing it in your d2c brand is another. If you'd like a hand running it smoothly day to day, tell us where you are and a person will reply, free.
Get help with this ↓What now?
Where are you?
One tap, and we point you to the right next step.