Read first
Three parcels, one phone number
At 1:40 am three orders arrive for the same product from three different names, with the same phone number and addresses that all say "near market". By the time the courier fails to deliver the third, the owner has paid freight on all three and the product is back in the cupboard. Similar posts appear in merchant forums; an app developer in a Shopify community thread asked merchants about exactly this and the WhatsApp-based checks they were trying. A trade blog on COD fraud describes the same pattern.
Signs of a fake or prank order
| Sign | Why it matters | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Phone number gibberish, repeated digits or the same number on several orders | Nobody will answer | Hold; OTP-verify or call |
| Address vague: landmark only, no house number | The rider cannot find it | Ask for a full address |
| Orders at odd hours, several within minutes | Bot or prank pattern | Hold; manual check |
| Pincode with past RTOs | Your data say it fails | Prepay or deposit only |
| Name and address mismatch (email says one thing, shipping another) | Possible fake | Confirm by WhatsApp |
| High-value COD order from a first-time buyer | More to lose per order | Part payment or verification |
| Many items of a high-margin product in one COD order | A competitor or prankster can do damage cheaply | Verify before packing |
Checks, from cheap to strong
- Phone OTP at checkout. A buyer who gets an OTP on the number they typed has a working phone. It stops a lot of random orders. Your store app or a checkout plugin does it.
- WhatsApp or IVR confirmation after the order. Send a message asking the buyer to confirm; no reply in a set time means hold. See how to set up COD verification.
- A minimum order value or a COD fee for COD orders, shown before checkout.
- A part payment. A small online advance on COD orders makes a prank costly and filters the unserious.
- Rules by pincode and order band, from your own RTO data; see how to cut RTO on COD orders.
- A manual review queue for orders with signs, checked once or twice a day.
- A blocklist of phone numbers, addresses and pincodes tied to past RTOs or refused parcels.
Handle personal data with care: keep the list to what you need, for the reason you collected it, and do not share it publicly. Your privacy notice should say you use order data to prevent fraud.
Build a blocklist that works
- Start a sheet with columns: phone, address, pincode, date, reason, parcels returned.
- Add a number after a second RTO or a refusal with no reason, not after one failed attempt: honest buyers also miss deliveries.
- Block at checkout where your store allows it, or hold at review.
- Review the list every month. Remove entries that have gone cold.
- Share patterns, not names. A rival is rarely a single number; the sign is repetition.
When someone targets you on purpose
A competitor or an angry ex-customer can place many COD orders to drain your cash. Signs: many orders from different names but one pattern of address wording, one IP, one device or one time window. Pause COD for a day, turn on OTP and part payment, keep the evidence (order exports, timestamps, messages) and report serious, repeated harassment to the police or the cybercrime portal. A lawyer can advise on a notice if you can identify the source.
General information, not legal advice. Keep records and avoid public accusations until you are sure who is behind the orders.
What usually goes wrong
- Blocking whole pincodes on hearsay, not data.
- Treating every failed delivery as fake; many are honest misses. See what an NDR is.
- Adding so many checks that real buyers drop at checkout. Test the effect on conversion.
- Keeping orders on hold with no message, so the genuine buyers cancel.
- No log, so the same fake sender returns under another name.
Fake orders are different from a normal RTO. A normal RTO rate for COD sits in the published band of 25–38% of COD orders; fake orders push yours above it, so a sudden jump is your cue to look for them.
Apply it to your store
Export last month's COD RTOs and look for repeated phones, similar addresses and odd hours. If you find a pattern, turn on OTP and a hold queue first. If you want us to look at your pattern, tell us where you are. For the decision to keep or end COD overall, see should I stop offering cash on delivery.
Questions people ask
How do I know an order is fake?
Look for a phone that does not work or repeats, a vague address, odd hours, several orders in minutes and pincodes with past returns. Two or three signs together justify a check before dispatch.
Is it legal to block a customer?
A store can refuse to ship to a number or address with a history of refused or fake orders. Keep your reason and records, keep personal data limited and use it only for fraud prevention.
Does OTP verification stop all fake orders?
No, but it removes many random ones. Combine it with a confirmation message and rules by pincode and order value.
Where these numbers come from
- RTO rate on COD orders across sources: 25–38% of COD orders (all India; Razorpay 25 to 30, ClickPost 37.5, other vendors 28 to 35; vendor blogs, not audited). Reported: Razorpay blog (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.
Fees, rates and rents change. Check the official source before you pay or sign anything.
Operations · D2C brand
More on operations for a d2c brand
23 pages on this. You are on number 3.
- How many days of stock should a D2C brand keep?
- Should my D2C brand stop offering cash on delivery?
- How do I block fake and prank COD orders on my D2C store?
- How does a D2C brand avoid running out of stock before a festive sale?
- Should my D2C brand start with a white-label product or a custom one?
- How do I set up COD verification by OTP or WhatsApp for my D2C store?
- How should a D2C brand handle shelf life and expiry dates on its products?
- A customer says the parcel did not arrive. How should my D2C brand respond?
Reading about it is one thing; doing it in your d2c brand is another. If you'd like a hand running it smoothly day to day, tell us where you are and a person will reply, free.
Get help with this ↓What now?
Where are you?
One tap, and we point you to the right next step.