Read first
Sixty parcels, twenty come back
A good week on Instagram brings sixty orders from DMs, almost all COD. The courier delivers forty. Twenty come back, some refused at the door, some with a wrong address, a few from people who never meant to buy. The founder paid to send all sixty and to take twenty back. This is the economic shape of the model: very low cost to find customers, and a high cost when the order fails.
The general per-order method is in one order's profit and loss and contribution margin. This page applies it to a brand where COD is most of the sales.
What is reported for COD
| Point | Reported | How far to trust it |
|---|---|---|
| COD share of Indian D2C orders | 50–65% of orders, higher in tier 2 and 3 | Vendor estimates; no audited figure |
| COD RTO | 25–38% of COD orders across sources; one network 37.51% of COD orders | Vendors; one network's data |
| Prepaid RTO | 2–5% of prepaid orders | Vendors |
| Cost of one failed order | ₹150–300 per order | Planning figure from a gateway's guide |
| COD handling fee | Higher of ₹35 or 1.5% of order value | One courier calculator |
| Fake and low-intent COD orders | Vendors put them at 8 to 10% or 20% of COD orders; no owner data | Unverified vendor figures |
A worked example
Our example, not a real brand. A ₹799 personal-care product with GST at 5%, landed cost ₹280, packaging ₹35, shipping ₹55, COD fee ₹35, prepaid RTO 3%, customer returns 8%. We vary COD share and COD RTO. The table shows contribution per order placed, before ads, and after ads of ₹250 per order.
| COD share | COD RTO | Before ads | After ₹250 of ads |
|---|---|---|---|
| 40% | 30% | about ₹236 | about −₹14 |
| 65% | 25% | about ₹216 | about −₹34 |
| 65% | 30% | about ₹201 | about −₹49 |
| 65% | 37.5% | about ₹178 | about −₹72 |
| 80% | 30% | about ₹180 | about −₹70 |
| 80% | 37.5% | about ₹152 | about −₹98 |
Read the columns. Before ads, the brand keeps ₹150 to ₹245 an order, enough to pay a small fixed cost if the audience is free. After paid ads, every row loses money. The Instagram-led model therefore works only as long as customers come from the founder's own reach and word of mouth, not from paid ads.
The first fixes
- Confirm every COD order before dispatch by a call or a WhatsApp message with the order summary.
- Offer a small prepaid discount. Every prepaid order avoids the COD fee and most of the failure risk.
- Block repeat refusers and pincodes with high failure; see block fake COD orders.
- Act on failed deliveries within a day; see NDR explained.
- Raise order value with a bundle, so shipping and fees are spread; see bundles and combos.
- Keep a returns cushion in cash; see cash stuck in COD.
If you are small, or already bigger
A starter brand with a few orders a day can run the whole model on a phone and a spreadsheet; track RTO from the first week. A brand past 50 orders a day needs order confirmation as a routine, a second courier and a clear line between orders you will take and ones you will not. A brand that wants paid ads should first fix prepaid share, since the table shows paid ads and heavy COD rarely pay.
What usually goes wrong
- Counting every DM as a sale.
- Shipping without confirming the address and the order.
- Using the same price for COD and prepaid.
- Ignoring failed deliveries until the courier returns them.
- Moving to paid ads while COD share is still high.
- Not keeping a record of refusers.
This page is general information, not financial advice. The example uses assumed inputs; use your own COD share and RTO.
Work out your COD model
To work through your own numbers, tell us your COD share.
Questions people ask
Should I stop taking COD?
Not always. COD brings buyers who will not pay online. Check contribution at your COD share and RTO before deciding; see stop COD or keep it.
How many COD orders are fake?
Vendor figures of 8 to 10% and 20% are unverified. Measure refusals by pincode and by customer.
Is a prepaid discount worth it?
It can be, if it costs less than the extra COD fee and failure risk it removes. Run your numbers.
These are ballpark figures to plan with, not a forecast for your business. Your own quotes and numbers come first.
Where these numbers come from
- RTO rate on COD orders across sources: 25–38% of COD orders (all India; Razorpay 25 to 30, ClickPost 37.5, other vendors 28 to 35; vendor blogs, not audited). Reported: Razorpay blog (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.
- RTO rate on COD orders, one logistics network, FY2026: 37.51% of COD orders (all India D2C; ClickPost network, brands with 1,000+ COD shipments; vendor data). Reported: ClickPost (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.
- RTO rate on prepaid orders across sources: 2–5% of prepaid orders (all India; vendor blogs; one vendor shows 20 to 30, treated as an outlier). Reported: Shipprime (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.
- What one RTO order costs: ₹150–300 per order (all India; Razorpay buffer figure; ClickPost models ₹350 on a ₹1,200 order (range ₹285 to 490)). Reported: ClickPost (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.
- COD handling fee as modelled by one courier calculator: Higher of ₹35 or 1.5% of order value (all India; a calculator assumption, not a tariff; other sources give ₹25 to ₹50 or 1.5 to 2.5%). Reported: ClickPost (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.
Fees, rates and rents change. Check the official source before you pay or sign anything.
What now?
Where are you?
One tap, and we point you to the right next step.