Read first
A phone notification says it is cheaper
Your distributor's salesman comes on Tuesday. On Monday night an app showed you the same detergent for less, with delivery by morning and a credit line. You know the distributor, you owe him money, and he gets you your fast movers. The question is not which one is good but where each is cheaper and what you give up.
What are the options?
| Option | What the retailer gets | What was reported | Caveat |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cash-and-carry store | Buy in bulk at the store, or order on its app; a loyalty bonus on monthly purchases | Bonus of 1–2.5% of purchases. One such chain's managing director said its gross margin was about 5%, and a distributor said 1% was left after a 4% cashback to wholesalers (5% stated; 1% after cashback) | Programme terms change; the bonus excludes oil, ghee and sugar and has a monthly cap |
| B2B ordering apps (marketplaces for retailers) | Packaged goods, staples and long-tail items, delivered, often with a credit line | Credit of ₹50,000–5,00,000 at onboarding or checkout; one platform reported 90% of sales of its FMCG sales came from orders under a single case, with no minimum order | Reports are from 2021 to 2025; credit cycles have tightened |
| A retail-chain partner app that also routes customer orders | A refundable POS deposit and an extra margin on app orders were reported for the JioMart Partner scheme | ₹3,000 deposit (2021); 3% extra margin (2022 survey) | Stale: ask the company for the current terms |
| ONDC apps | Selling to customers rather than buying stock; seller apps charge a monthly fee | ₹200–2,000 per month in a generic guide, low confidence | That is a way to sell, not to buy, and not covered here |
A Mumbai survey in 2022 found retailer margins on two B2B platforms of JioMart 7-15%; the other platform 8-14%; most of the retailers surveyed bought from more than 10 distributors and used the apps in addition.
Why might an app be cheaper, and why might it not?
An app can cut one or two layers out of the chain, and in 2021 the platform that was reported to be 15 to 34% cheaper was doing exactly that. Companies also supply some platforms directly, which can make prices on the app lower than the distributor's price list. A Maharashtra distributor told Reuters he lost customers because of the price. Udaan has claimed a saving of 3 to 4% from cutting layers.
Against that: platforms have retreated or changed terms (some B2B players shut down or pulled back; credit cycles on the apps have shortened from 30 days to 14 in one report). A discount can be a launch offer, not a lasting price. Delivery may carry a fee or a minimum. Your distributor gives you a salesman, a beat, returns, schemes and credit that an app may not. And what a brand sells through an app may differ from what the distributor sells in the same lane.
How do I test them?
- Take your top 20 items by value sold. Write down the price you pay your distributor, including the scheme you actually receive.
- Check the same items on the app or at the cash-and-carry and write the price, GST, any delivery or handling fee, and any minimum.
- Compare the landed cost per piece, not the headline price. Include whether you get a proper GST invoice.
- Buy a small basket from each for four weeks and note on-time delivery, short supply and returns.
- Keep the distributor for what is cheapest or most reliable there, and use the app or the store for the rest: the long tail and one-off items, small packs and the occasional gap.
If the app's price is much lower than the distributor's price list, ask the distributor why. He may match it on some items, or you may learn that the scheme he gave you was less than it looked; see trade schemes.
What do I give up if I switch the core buying?
- The relationship. A distributor who loses your core orders will not extend credit or push your returns.
- Credit. An app's credit line may be larger, but it has an interest-free period of days (₹5,000-2,00,000; up to 14 days interest-free), after which charges apply. Know the cost.
- Returns. Check the policy for damaged and near-expiry stock; see returning near-expiry stock.
- Reliability. Delivery within 24 hours is the promise; check it in your own lane.
What usually goes wrong
- Comparing the app's price with the MRP instead of with what your distributor charges you.
- Buying a month of stock from an app because of a discount, then holding slow stock.
- Using the app's credit line like income and being unable to repay at the end of the free period.
- Moving all your buying to one platform that later changes its terms or leaves your area.
- Missing the GST invoice that you need for your records.
Apply it to your own case
Make the comparison table for your top 20 items this week, with one column for each supplier you use. Highlight where the difference is bigger than the delivery fee and the effort of a second order. Move those lines and keep the rest. Use the form at the end of this page if you want us to help structure the comparison for your lane.
Questions people ask
Is a B2B app cheaper than a distributor?
On some items and at some dates, yes: retailers reported ₹115 against ₹154 on one combo in 2021. It is not true for every item or today, so test your top 20 items.
Do cash-and-carry stores give a bonus to kiranas?
One chain's programme paid 1–2.5% of purchases on monthly purchases above a floor, excluding oil, ghee and sugar. Check the current terms.
Should I use only apps?
Not for the core range. Distributors give a salesman, schemes, returns and credit, and apps can change terms. Use apps for the long tail.
Where these numbers come from
- A retailer paid ₹115 for a combo on a B2B app against ₹154 from the distributor (reports from retailers and distributors, 2021): 15–34% cheaper on the app (India, Dec 2021). Reported: Medianama, JioMart and kirana distributors (6 Dec 2021), checked 14 November 2026.
- Retailer margin on two B2B platforms, Mumbai survey (Sep 2022, stale); most retailers use more than 10 distributors: JioMart 7-15%; the other platform 8-14% (Mumbai). Reported: NDTV Profit on the Kotak Mumbai survey (6 Sep 2022), checked 14 November 2026.
- Cash-and-carry loyalty bonus on monthly purchases, 1% at ₹50,000-74,999 up to 2.5% at ₹4,00,000+; cap ₹10,000 a month; oil, ghee, sugar excluded (programme terms change): 1–2.5% of purchases (India, Sep 2024 archived page). Reported: Cash-and-carry chain Smart Kirana programme page, Wayback copy 10 Sep 2024, checked 14 November 2026.
- A cash-and-carry chain's stated gross margin, and what was left after a 4% cashback to wholesalers (one anonymous distributor, 2022): 5% stated; 1% after cashback (India). Reported: The Ken, hour of reckoning for cash-and-carry (1 Feb 2022), checked 14 November 2026.
- Credit offered to retailers on B2B platforms at onboarding or checkout: ₹50,000–5,00,000 (India). Reported: Redseer (Sep 2024) says ₹1-5 lakh at onboarding; Fortune India (Aug 2025) says ₹50,000-5,00,000 at checkout, checked 14 November 2026.
- Refundable POS deposit and extra margin offered to partner kiranas (2021 and 2022 sources, stale: ask the company): ₹3,000 deposit (2021); 3% extra margin (2022 survey) (India). Reported: Newsmill (11 Jul 2021) and NDTV Profit on a Kotak survey (6 Sep 2022), checked 14 November 2026.
- Typical seller-app subscription on ONDC (ONDC itself charges no registration fee); small per-order fee on top: ₹200–2,000 per month (India; generic guide, low confidence). Reported: IRIS MSME, ONDC seller registration (c 2026), checked 14 November 2026.
- B2B platform credit line for retailers, interest-free period (2021 launch, repeated 2026): ₹5,000-2,00,000; up to 14 days interest-free (India). Reported: Business Today, wholesale credit programme (24 Aug 2021); Unicommerce (6 Mar 2026), checked 14 November 2026.
Fees, rates and rents change. Check the official source before you pay or sign anything.
Operations · Kirana store
More on operations for a kirana store
20 pages on this. You are on number 9.
- How do I find and clear slow-moving stock in my kirana?
- What do I do if my distributor stops giving credit or short-supplies me?
- Can I buy from cash-and-carry or B2B apps cheaper than from my distributor?
- How do I protect my kirana from fake QR stickers and soundbox fraud?
- How do I store grains, dal and sacks in a kirana and avoid pests and damp?
- What do company salesmen want from my kirana, and how do I refuse extra stock before quarter end?
- What does a kirana store need ready in the last two weeks before opening?
- What is a trade scheme, and how do I read a free carton or extra percent offer?
Reading about it is one thing; doing it in your kirana store is another. If you'd like a hand running it smoothly day to day, tell us where you are and a person will reply, free.
Get help with this ↓What now?
Where are you?
One tap, and we point you to the right next step.
What to read next
Related questions
Where this fits in your journey
- Step 2 of 9How to get more customers into your kirana store: Check your top 20 prices against the apps→
- Step 4 of 8How to raise money for stock and growth in a kirana store: Ask distributors for credit before you ask a lender→
- Step 8 of 14How to open a kirana store in India, step by step: Choose distributors and agree credit→