Read first
Ten cartons, one free
The offer is on a slip: buy ten, get one carton free, until Saturday. It sounds like ten per cent. It might be, if you would have bought ten anyway. If you would have bought six, you are buying four extra cartons to get one. Read a scheme as arithmetic, and as stock.
What kinds of scheme are there?
| Type | How it works | What to watch |
|---|---|---|
| Free goods (buy X get Y) | Extra cartons or pieces with a larger order | The extra stock you must hold to get it |
| Introductory discount | A lower price to launch a new item | Whether customers will actually buy it |
| Slab discount on volume | A higher discount at higher order sizes | A slab above your real sales makes you overbuy |
| Cash discount for prompt payment | A reduction for paying within a few days | Often worth more than a free carton; it costs only cash you already have |
| Display or visibility incentive | Money or goods for a branded display | The space it takes and what it displaces |
| Festival schemes | Seasonal offers before a festival | Whether the stock will sell before the date passes |
How do I turn a scheme into a margin?
Take the simplest case with assumed numbers: a carton of 24 packs, MRP ₹50 each, bought at ₹43 a pack (a margin of 14% on MRP). The scheme: buy ten, get one carton free.
- Ten cartons cost 10 × 24 × ₹43 = ₹10,320 and you receive 11 cartons, or 264 packs.
- Cost per pack falls from ₹43 to ₹10,320 ÷ 264 = about ₹39.09.
- Margin on MRP rises from 14% to (50 − 39.09) ÷ 50 = about 21.8%.
- But if you would have sold only 8 cartons in the period, you hold 3 extra cartons (72 packs, about ₹2,800 of stock at the scheme cost) beyond your normal cover.
Whether that pays depends on what you do with the extra: sell it in the next fortnight and the higher margin is real; sit on it for three months and the cash, the shelf space and the expiry risk eat the gain. Every scheme needs this second sum: how long until the extra stock is gone.
The rupee numbers are an illustration with assumed prices, not any brand's actual terms. Use the figures on your own invoice.
What does the whole chain look like?
A kirana is only the last link. One trade source gives an illustrative ladder for an MRP of 100: the retailer buys at about 85, the distributor at about 76 and the brand nets about 70-74 (85 / 76 / 70-74). The brand gives the whole trade about 25% of its price. Brand-side figures say schemes add 5–15% of sales to a brand's cost of sales, and that retailer margins run national pull brands 5-10; regional 10-18; new brands 18-25+, higher for newer brands and lower for the biggest. Those are brand-side views and the numbers differ between sources; see margin by category.
The practical point: the biggest brands give you the least margin and the fastest turn; newer brands give more but may not sell. A scheme on a famous product is usually a thin extra. A scheme on an unknown product asks you to take a risk.
How do I test a scheme before taking it?
- Write the price per piece after the scheme and the margin on MRP.
- Check how many pieces you sold of this item in the last month. Divide by four to get a week.
- Work out how many weeks of stock the scheme order gives you. A trade platform calls a product slow if it sits more than 4 to 6 weeks.
- Check the expiry or best before dates on what you will receive, and the shelf life you need. A short date on scheme stock is a warning.
- Ask whether the distributor takes back unsold or near-expiry stock from a scheme order; see returning near-expiry stock.
- Check that the scheme appears on the invoice with the end date.
Cash discount is often the clearest scheme. A discount for paying within a few days costs you nothing but your cash, and the cash you have is the one thing a slow-moving carton does not return. If you carry cash from a quiet week, ask what the distributor gives for prompt payment; see distributor credit.
What usually goes wrong
- Counting the free carton as profit without counting the extra stock.
- Taking a slab discount above your real sales to reach the next band.
- Buying a scheme item with a short expiry, then selling at a loss.
- Taking a verbal scheme that never reaches the invoice.
- Putting scheme stock at eye level and starving the faster seller; see shelf layout.
Apply it to your own case
Take the scheme you were offered last week and work the two sums: margin per piece and weeks of cover. If you are unsure, ask the salesman for the scheme in writing and show the numbers to a second shopkeeper. If you want help building a simple scheme calculator for your top 20 items, use the form at the end of this page.
Questions people ask
Is a free carton scheme worth it?
Only if you will sell the extra stock soon. Work out the price per piece after the scheme and the weeks of cover it gives.
Which is better, a cash discount or a free carton?
A cash discount for early payment is often cleaner because it adds no stock. Compare both as margin per piece.
What is the margin on a branded product?
It depends on the brand. A brand-side source gives national pull brands 5-10; regional 10-18; new brands 18-25+ of MRP for national, regional and new brands respectively. See the margin table.
Where these numbers come from
- Illustrative price ladder for MRP 100: retailer buys at 85, distributor at 76, brand nets 70-74: 85 / 76 / 70-74 (India general trade, illustrative). Reported: Kirana Club, FMCG distributor and kirana margins (trade-media platform, brand-side view, Feb 2026), checked 14 November 2026.
- Total margin manufacturers give the trade, shared by distributor, wholesaler and retailer (unnamed speaker, Nov 2024): 25% (India FMCG). Reported: Times of India, why FMCG brands love quick-commerce apps (27 Nov 2024), checked 14 November 2026.
- What trade schemes add to a brand's cost of sales (brand-side view): 5–15% of sales (India). Reported: Kirana Club, FMCG distributor and kirana margins (trade-media platform, brand-side view, Feb 2026), checked 14 November 2026.
- Retailer margin by brand type, % of MRP (brand-side view): national pull brands 5-10; regional 10-18; new brands 18-25+ (India). Reported: Kirana Club, FMCG distributor and kirana margins (trade-media platform, brand-side view, Feb 2026), checked 14 November 2026.
Fees, rates and rents change. Check the official source before you pay or sign anything.
Operations · Kirana store
More on operations for a kirana store
20 pages on this. You are on number 14.
- What do company salesmen want from my kirana, and how do I refuse extra stock before quarter end?
- What does a kirana store need ready in the last two weeks before opening?
- What is a trade scheme, and how do I read a free carton or extra percent offer?
- Which festival items should a kirana stock, and how early?
- How do I handle stock-outs of atta, dal and oil on peak days?
- What do I do with scheme stock I cannot sell?
- How do I return near-expiry or damaged stock to the company or distributor?
- What do I do in a power cut with a fridge full of milk and curd?
Reading about it is one thing; doing it in your kirana store is another. If you'd like a hand running it smoothly day to day, tell us where you are and a person will reply, free.
Get help with this ↓What now?
Where are you?
One tap, and we point you to the right next step.
What to read next
Related questions
Where this fits in your journey
- Step 4 of 8Kirana not making money? Find the leak and fix it: Turn slow and scheme stock back into cash→
- Step 4 of 9How to run a kirana store well, day to day: Reorder by sales and clear what is not moving→
- Step 8 of 14How to open a kirana store in India, step by step: Choose distributors and agree credit→
- Step 3 of 8Working in a kirana store: pay, learning and the path to owner: Learn the business, not just the counter→