Read first
Sales are the same, the money is less
Last year ₹2.5 lakh a month left ₹30,000 after costs. This year the sales look the same and what is left is ₹18,000. Rent went up, the helper wants more, and every regular says the app is cheaper. Margin does not usually collapse in one place; it leaks from several. The job is to find which leaks are yours before changing anything.
Five reasons, and how to test each
| Cause | What it looks like | How to check it |
|---|---|---|
| Mix shift to staples | Sales hold but the share of oil, sugar, atta and rice rises | Sales by category this month against a year ago. A cash-and-carry MD's view of kirana margins is oil and sugar 1%; spices 15%; impulse and personal care earn 11–19% gross and 11–20% gross |
| App price pressure | Regulars quote the app's price on a few items | List ten items regulars compare. Note what the app charges against your buying price. One retailer paid ₹115 on a B2B app for a combo that his distributor sold at ₹154 in 2021 |
| Scheme stock and expiry | Cartons sitting on the floor, write-offs rising | Stock older than 60 days, and what you threw away last month. See expired stock |
| Costs up, prices not | Rent and helper pay rose; MRP-bound items cannot | Fixed cost as a share of sales, this year against last. See monthly costs |
| Udhaar losses | A balance of old credit that no one pays | Credit older than 60 days, and what you wrote off. See stopping udhaar |
The market side is real but contested. A trade body claims quick commerce has taken 25–30% of kirana business in metros, an untested claim. A PwC survey with Kirana Club of 508 retailers reported a 28% fall in physical-store footfall in tier-1 cities, while another survey of 551 retailers found 64% calling the impact marginal. They measure different things, so treat each as a signal rather than a verdict.
What helps, in order of effort
- Count first. Gross margin by category for three months. Without it, every other step is guesswork.
- Move the shelf. Put higher-margin lines at eye level and the counter, and staples where people find them anyway.
- Do not match every app price. Pick the ten items regulars compare and decide a price; owners quoted in the press offer a small discount, in the range of 2 to 3 per cent on larger bills, instead of matching.
- Stop buying on schemes you cannot sell. Take a scheme only on fast movers, and only when the credit note arrives in writing.
- Cut the leaks, the expiry and the old udhaar, before raising prices.
- Sell what an app does not: home-made items, loose goods, fresh produce where you can vouch for it, credit for trusted regulars.
These are patterns reported by owners in the press, not a tested recipe. See the margin by category for the ranges and the P&L for the layout of your own month.
What usually goes wrong
- Raising all prices at once and losing the regulars you are keeping the shop for.
- Cutting the helper to save wages, then losing the sales he brought.
- Blaming the apps for a margin that was already thin from scheme stock.
- Moving to a larger shop on rent the new margin cannot carry.
Margin figures are published ranges and analysts' views, not audited data. Survey figures are from small or sponsor-linked samples and are labelled by who said them.
Your own diagnosis
If the answer is a shop that does not cover its costs, go to why a kirana is not profitable. If sales themselves are falling, read what to do when sales fall.
Questions people ask
Should I match quick-commerce prices?
On a handful of items regulars compare, perhaps. Matching all of them with your margins usually loses money. Decide ten items and leave the rest.
Is the fall in margin because of quick commerce?
Partly in some cities, but the claims are contested and the shift to staples, schemes and cost rises explain much of the squeeze on its own.
These are ballpark figures to plan with, not a forecast for your business. Your own quotes and numbers come first.
Where these numbers come from
- Kirana margin on oil and sugar; on spices (cash-and-carry MD, 2022): oil and sugar 1%; spices 15% (India). Reported: Outlook Business, interview with the MD of a cash-and-carry chain (1 Apr 2022), checked 14 November 2026.
- Gross margin on beverages and impulse items: 11–19% gross (India). Reported: Accountune, kirana store profit margin (31 Aug 2026; indicative ranges, vendor blog, no data), checked 14 November 2026.
- Gross margin on personal care: 11–20% gross (India). Reported: Accountune, kirana store profit margin (31 Aug 2026; indicative ranges, vendor blog, no data), checked 14 November 2026.
- Share of kirana business quick commerce is said to have taken (trade-body claim, not audited): 25–30% (metros). Reported: CNBC-TV18, kirana stores struggle for survival as quick commerce captures 30 percent of their market (page dated 4 Jan 2026; Sept 2024 quotes), checked 14 November 2026.
- Fall in physical-store footfall reported in tier-1 cities (PwC with Kirana Club, 508 retailers, Mar 2025): 28% (tier-1 cities). Reported: Upstox News on the PwC survey (Mar 2025), checked 11 November 2026.
- Retailers saying quick-commerce impact was marginal or very little (Kirana Club, 551 retailers, May 2024; low-grade source): 64% (India). Reported: LinkedIn post by an analyst citing the Kirana Club survey, checked 11 November 2026.
Fees, rates and rents change. Check the official source before you pay or sign anything.
Money and tax · Kirana store
More on money and tax for a kirana store
30 pages on this. You are on number 30.
- What margin does a kirana make on staples, packaged goods and loose items?
- How many sales a day does a kirana store need to break even?
- My kirana looks profitable on paper but I have no cash. Where did it go?
- How much money should I keep aside after my kirana store opens?
- How do I fund a kirana store: savings, Mudra, NBFC or family?
- Why do banks reject kirana store loans, and how do I build a credit record?
- How much can I pay myself from a kirana store, and how do I keep shop money apart from home money?
- Why is my kirana's margin shrinking while costs keep rising?
Reading about it is one thing; doing it in your kirana store is another. If you'd like a hand working out your own numbers, tell us where you are and a person will reply, free.
Get help with this ↓What now?
Where are you?
One tap, and we point you to the right next step.