PG or paying guest accommodation · Chapter · 10 questions

When it's not working

My PG is losing money, half empty, or has had a notice. How do I find and fix the problem?

A PG can be busy and still lose money, or lose half its beds in a season. This chapter starts with a six-step diagnosis of why a PG is not making money, then takes the specific bad days: beds empty after a competitor opens or rules bite, a PG sealed or its water and power cut and what you owe residents, a loan on a building that will not fill, and a cash crunch with a payment order. It then covers the neighbours' complaint, renegotiating the lease, turning the PG into another kind of stay and deciding whether to close or continue. General information, not legal or financial advice.

Useful when you want to: fix profit or cash problems · close it properly

  1. 01PG or paying guest accommodationWhy isn't my PG making money? How to find the real problemCheck six things in order: the lease or loan against what the building can carry, the staff bill, occupancy against break-even, collections, the cost of meals and power, and tax on the landlord's rent. In our models the biggest causes are a lease above about 21% of full-occupancy revenue and hired staff in a small PG: with two hired staff a 10-bed home PG loses -₹11,324 at 70% occupancy (-19.5%), -₹4,223 at 85% (-6%), ₹511 at 95% (0.6%). A PG can be full and still lose money.
  2. 02PG or paying guest accommodationHalf my beds are empty after a co-living building opened nearby. What do I do?First put a number on the loss: each empty bed costs about about ₹4,734 in the 10-bed owned house and ₹6,106 in the 50-bed leased PG, which is 57% and 63% of the bed's rent a month. Then check whether the cause is the new building, a seasonal gap or enforcement in your area, because each needs a different response. We found no sourced case of a new co-living building cutting a nearby PG's occupancy, but owners in Bengaluru reported occupancy down 30 to 50 percent, as owners in Marathahalli, Mahadevapura, Whitefield and Electronic City reported for other reasons. Cut fixed costs, reprice for new residents and set a 60-day review.
  3. 03PG or paying guest accommodationMy PG was sealed or its water and power were cut. What do I owe residents, and what can I do?You owe residents what you took for time you cannot provide: the unused part of the rent and their deposit, less any dues you can itemise, and their belongings. The Karnataka High Court's PG order says belongings may not be withheld on closure. In Bengaluru, 10 days proposed by the Greater Bengaluru Authority; 15 to 21 days indicated by the court have been discussed in court, not as a final rule. Answer any notice in writing with documents, and talk to a lawyer the same day.
  4. 04StaysA notice or an inspector has arrived at my stay. What do I do first?Be polite, read what you have been given before you say anything, note the date, who sent it and what it asks, then gather your papers, answer before the deadline in writing, keep everything running safely, and tell the people living there what is happening. Do not lock out guests or residents, cut their water or power or hide records. Take advice from a local lawyer the same day. The court in Karnataka has indicated that occupants need not leave if the stay complies with the notice, so a calm reply with papers is often what turns a closure into an inspection.
  5. 05PG or paying guest accommodationThe society or neighbours are complaining and want my PG shut. What do I do?Do four things in this order: read the notice and your own papers (agreement, landlord consent, bye-laws, licences), fix what the complaint is really about (noise, gate traffic, parking, rubbish), meet the society before you reply in writing, and keep a record of every step. Do not ignore a notice or lock out residents. In the reported cases we found, courts did not side with the PG where the use was not allowed, so the strongest position is a PG that is allowed, quiet and visibly well run.
  6. 06PG or paying guest accommodationI took a loan for a PG building that is not filling. What are my options?Work out the monthly gap between what the PG earns at its real occupancy and its fixed costs including the EMI, then talk to the lender before you miss a payment. Lenders can sometimes restructure, extend the term or give a short moratorium if you show a plan. Options beyond that are changing the use, leasing the building to an operator, selling, or adding beds only if the numbers allow. Do not borrow more to cover EMIs: it deepens the gap. For scale, an EMI of ₹10,685 per month on a Rs 5 lakh loan has to be earned from the PG every month.
  7. 07PG or paying guest accommodationMy PG is running out of cash. What are my options?List every payment due in the next 13 weeks, collect what is owed, cut what is idle, pay in an order that keeps the PG running, and talk early to your landlord, staff and lender. Do not use residents' deposits: they are money you owe, and spending them leads to refund disputes. If the gap is structural, not temporary, you need a different plan; see not making money and close or continue.
  8. 08PG or paying guest accommodationHow do I renegotiate my PG's lease rent when beds are empty?Start with your own numbers: the rent your building can carry at the occupancy you are actually getting, and what you lose each month at the current rent. Take that to the landlord with evidence of the lane (empty beds nearby, rents on listings) and a specific offer: a lower rent for a fixed period, a step-up as occupancy returns, or a longer lease in return for a lower rate. Be ready with a fallback, because a landlord who knows you cannot leave may not move, and a lock-in may bind you.
  9. 09PG or paying guest accommodationIs turning my PG into a hostel or homestay a better fit?A hostel or homestay is a better fit only if you can reach guests who stay short and pay more per night, and the building is sanctioned for that use. A new name does not escape PG rules: in Karnataka the High Court treats a hostel or co-living building as a PG if it is one in substance. GST also changes, because the exemption for long stays does not cover short ones. Trial a few rooms before you convert the building, and count cleaning, commissions and desk staff in the sums.
  10. 10PG or paying guest accommodationShould I close my PG or keep going?Close or sell a PG when it loses money at an occupancy you can honestly reach, when fixing the cause would cost more than you can carry, and when the lease or loan will get heavier by waiting. Keep going if the loss is from a few empty beds you can fill, a lease you can renegotiate, or a staff cost you can cut. Count three things first: what an empty bed costs you, how many months of loss your cash covers, and what you must pay out on the day you stop.

Menu

Read

Ask an expert Ask an expertFree, real peopleHub
Ask an expert