PG or paying guest accommodation · 5 min read

How do I renegotiate my PG's lease rent when beds are empty?

The short answer

Start with your own numbers: the rent your building can carry at the occupancy you are actually getting, and what you lose each month at the current rent. Take that to the landlord with evidence of the lane (empty beds nearby, rents on listings) and a specific offer: a lower rent for a fixed period, a step-up as occupancy returns, or a longer lease in return for a lower rate. Be ready with a fallback, because a landlord who knows you cannot leave may not move, and a lock-in may bind you.

Not sure about your case? Ask an expert, free ↓

The meeting with the landlord, in the third empty month

The owner of a 40-bed leased PG walks into the landlord's office with a printout. Fifteen beds have been empty since the layoffs and the rent has not moved. The landlord says that the lease is the lease and that the building next door has a waiting list of tenants. The owner has no figure beyond 'we are losing money'.

Step 1: know what rent the building can carry

In our 50-bed leased model with meals, ₹1,02,774 a month, about 21.2% of full-occupancy revenue; about ₹61,549 (12.7%) to earn a 10% margin If occupancy falls, the ceiling falls with it: ₹45,795 less a month at any lease (7.5 beds). Your own numbers will differ, but the method is the same: fixed costs excluding rent, contribution per occupied bed, and the occupancy you can count on.

FigureWhere it comes from
Fixed monthly cost excluding rentStaff, power, water, internet, upkeep, insurance, loan if any
Contribution per occupied bedRent per bed less food, power and other costs that rise with each resident. In the 50-bed model: ₹6,106 per occupied bed per month
Occupancy you can rely onThe last six months, not your strongest month
Rent the building can carryContribution per bed times occupied beds, less fixed costs, for a break-even or a margin you accept

Step 2: build the case

  • Your loss at today's rent, month by month, with your records.
  • The lane: how many PGs are empty, what rents are on listings, whether a co-living building has opened. See how to test demand.
  • Your track record: rent paid on time, building kept in order, a licence in place.
  • What it costs the landlord to lose you: months empty, brokerage on a new tenant, a building fitted for a PG that another PG tenant must also want.

Do not threaten to leave unless you can. A landlord who knows the lock-in binds you will wait. Read your lease first. See lease terms for a PG.

Step 3: make a specific ask, with something in return

AskWhat you offerWhy a landlord may agree
A lower rent for six monthsA step back up to the old rent as occupancy returnsLess risk of an empty building
Rent linked to occupancyA share above a floorHe shares the upside
A rent holiday for the weak monthsA longer lease or a shorter exitLonger certainty
A shorter lock-inA higher rent in later yearsA trade he can price
Rent paid on a fixed date, quarterly in advanceCash certaintyInterest on the advance
Landlord pays for a repair or fit-outA longer termValue kept in his building

Put whatever you agree in a signed addendum to the lease, not a message. See what a PG lease should say and the general rent negotiation page.

When to walk away

  • The rent you can carry is below the rent the landlord will accept, and the gap will not close in a year.
  • The lock-in's cost, month by month, is lower than the loss from staying.
  • The building has legal problems that will not go away. See what to check in a building.
  • Your deposit and fit-out are at risk if you wait. Plan the exit with the lease, the residents and the deposit in mind. See what happens to the lease and deposit when you exit.

If you are small, if you are large

Small. If you lease a few rooms from a landlord who lives upstairs, a conversation is often enough, with a written note of what you agree.

Large. Take a lawyer and a one-page model to the meeting. For a large building, expect the landlord to ask for a longer lease or a larger deposit in return for any cut.

What usually goes wrong

  • Going in with no figures.
  • Asking for a permanent cut with nothing offered.
  • Threatening to leave while locked in.
  • A verbal agreement that the landlord forgets.
  • Waiting until cash is gone before asking.

This is general information, not legal advice.

Apply it to your own case

If you share your rent, beds and occupancy, we can help you build the case for the meeting.

Questions people ask

Will a landlord cut rent when beds are empty?

Sometimes, if you show numbers and offer something in return. It is harder if the lock-in binds you and the lane is strong.

Can I leave before the lock-in ends?

Only as the lease allows. Read the exit clause and work out the cost of leaving against the cost of staying.

What should I ask for first?

A lower rent for a fixed period with a step-up as occupancy returns. It is easier for a landlord to accept than a permanent cut.

Should I tell the landlord my numbers?

Show enough to prove the case, such as occupancy and rent per bed, without handing over all your accounts.

This is general information, not legal advice. Have a lawyer read any agreement before you sign it.

Where these numbers come from

  1. The most lease a 50-bed PG with meals can carry and still break even at 85% occupancy: ₹1,02,774 a month, about 21.2% of full-occupancy revenue; about ₹61,549 (12.7%) to earn a 10% margin (50-bed leased model with meals, wages at Delhi's official floors). Ballpark Break-even lease = net with no lease = 102774. For a 10% margin at 85%: 102774 - 0.10 x 412250 = 61549. As a share of ₹4,85,000: 21.2% and 12.7%. Rule of thumb for owners: keep the lease at about a fifth of full-occupancy revenue or less, and lower still with more or better-paid staff.
  2. What 70% occupancy instead of 85% does to the 50-bed leased PG: ₹45,795 less a month at any lease (7.5 beds) (50-bed leased model with meals). Ballpark 7.5 beds x 6106 = 45795.
  3. What one more occupied bed adds in the 50-bed leased PG with meals: ₹6,106 per occupied bed per month (50-bed leased model with meals). Ballpark Average rent ₹9,700 x 0.98 = ₹9,506, minus food ₹2,500 and power ₹900 = ₹6,106.

Fees, rates and rents change. Check the official source before you pay or sign anything.

Place and setup · PG or paying guest accommodation

More on place and setup for a pg or paying guest accommodation

19 pages on this. You are on number 14.

  1. Which kind of PG should I start: student, professionals', ladies' or a small home PG?
  2. How many beds can I put in a room, and how much area per person is expected?
  3. How do I renegotiate my PG's lease rent when beds are empty?
  4. How much water and power do 20, 40 or 60 PG beds need?
  5. Should I buy, lease or use my own building for a PG?
  6. How do I test demand near a campus or office before I lease a PG building?
  7. What should a PG lease say: deposit, lock-in, rent rise, subletting and use?
  8. What should the landlord's written consent for a PG say?
All 19 on place and setup →

Reading about it is one thing; doing it in your pg or paying guest accommodation is another. If you'd like a hand choosing and setting up the right place, tell us where you are and a person will reply, free.

Get help with this ↓

What now?

Next question · 8 of 10 in When it's not workingIs turning my PG into a hostel or homestay a better fit? →

Where are you?

One tap, and we point you to the right next step.

Menu

Read

Ask an expert Ask an expertFree, real peopleHub
Ask an expert