PG or paying guest accommodation · 6 min read

How do I answer a one-star review about my PG's deposit or food?

The short answer

Reply once in public, calmly, in three lines: thank them, say you will check your records, and ask them to call. Then check the records and, if you owe money, pay it with a written statement and say so in a short follow-up. Do not argue the case, name the resident's room or payments, or threaten. The reply is for the next parent who reads it. Deposit and food are the two complaints you can prevent: write down every deduction with a photo, return the balance on a fixed date, and give the cook a weekly menu and a way to hear feedback.

Not sure about your case? Ask an expert, free ↓

The review that arrives on a Tuesday

A resident who left three weeks ago has written: 'Deposit not returned, food was terrible, owner does not pick up.' It has one star and it is the first thing a parent sees. You are angry because you deducted for a broken cupboard door and a month of unpaid mess charges, and you were never asked for the details.

The anger is real and the instinct to argue is strong. It is also the wrong move: the person you are writing for is not the one who left, it is the one who has not yet joined.

Why these two complaints

In the residents' accounts and orders we found, money on exit and food come up again and again. In one reported case, a group of tenants paid ₹31,500 in deposits and got ₹15,000 back after six months (one Bengaluru PG). A resident of a privately owned hostel in Hyderabad was asked for an advance of 10 months of rent, to be lost on early exit. And in another, a consumer forum in Kangra ordered a Greater Noida hostel to refund ₹30,000 of a ₹35,000 advance with 9 percent interest, plus ₹5,000 compensation and ₹5,000 costs. That hostel had not appeared before the forum despite notices, and the case went ahead without it. These are single cases, not a rate, and they show what a consumer complaint can cost. A consumer complaint can be filed: 2 years from cause of action; condonable for sufficient cause with recorded reasons (s69).

Reply in three lines

  1. Thank and acknowledge. 'Thank you for writing. We are sorry that your exit was not smooth.'
  2. Say what you will do. 'We will look at your file and send you a written statement of the deposit and deductions.'
  3. Move it offline. 'Please call us on this number between 10 and 12 so we can settle it.'

Do not mention the amount, the room, the payment mode or the reason for any deduction in public. Do not say the resident broke something or was rude. If the review is wrong on a plain fact, such as dates, correct it once in a neutral line. Then do what you said. When it is settled, add one line: 'We have sent the statement and the balance.' The reviewer may change or remove the review; if they do not, the line still helps the reader.

Settle the money with a written statement

One page, signed, handed or sent on the day the refund is made.
LineWhat to show
Deposit paidDate, amount, receipt number
Rent and mess dues, if anyMonth, amount, date of reminder
Damage deductionsWhat, which room, a dated photo from check-in and check-out, the cost of repair
Notice period shortfallThe clause in the agreement and the dates
BalanceAmount returned, date, mode

Deductions without records are what lose arguments, in public and before a forum. If you have a deduction you can show, say so politely and stick to it. If you cannot show it, return the money. The deposit rules that apply to your PG, including any cap or refund period in your city or state, are in the agreements chapter, and some places limit what can be taken at all; check before you set terms.

Replying about food

A food review is usually true in part. Reply with the part you will act on: 'We have shared your comments with our cook and will review the menu this week.' Then do it. Ask two or three current residents for honest feedback on the same dish, change the menu if they agree, and tell the reviewer. Nothing wins a doubtful parent like a menu that visibly changed after a complaint.

A PG that gives meals pays, in our worked model, about ₹2,500 a month per resident (groceries ₹2,030 plus cooking gas ₹470), so a cook who is squeezed on budget is the usual cause of a watery dal. If your food is cheap because you are losing money on it, the review is a symptom of a pricing problem; see the money chapter.

What the review is worth

A complaint that is answered well is often more convincing than a perfect score. The next parent reads for how you behave when things go wrong. A short, factual reply that treats the person with respect is evidence. A long, defensive one is evidence too, of the opposite kind. If a review breaks Google's content rules, for example abuse or a post by someone who never stayed, you can flag it. A review that is only unfair stays.

Stop the next one

  • Photograph every room on check-in and check-out and keep the pictures with the register.
  • Write the deposit terms into the agreement and on the rule sheet, in the same words.
  • Return the balance on a fixed date and send the statement.
  • Give the cook a weekly menu and a monthly feedback meeting with a few residents.
  • Answer the phone, or say when you will call back. 'Owner does not pick up' is the review that hurts most.

By size

In a home PG with three guests, one angry review can be a third of all your reviews, and a call from you on the same day may settle it. In a fifty-bed PG, reviews arrive every week and need a person with the job, a template for the reply and a monthly note of what residents complained about. The general page on reviews for a stay covers how to ask for reviews and reply to them for any stay; this page is the PG version for the two commonest complaints.

What usually goes wrong

  • Arguing the details in the reply, so the whole dispute is public.
  • Naming the resident's room or the amounts.
  • A deduction with no photo, no receipt and no date.
  • Ignoring notices from a consumer forum.
  • Offering a refund only if the review is deleted, which is pressure that backfires.
  • Fixing the review, not the cause.

Apply it to your own PG

Pull your last six exits and check whether each has a written statement, a photo record and a refund date. Fill the gaps for the next exit, starting today. If you are already in a dispute over a deposit, take advice before you reply in public, and tell us where you are if you want a second view.

Questions people ask

Can I get a one-star review removed?

Only if it breaks Google's content policy, such as abuse, spam or a review from someone who never stayed. An unfair complaint stays, so reply and fix.

Can I deduct from the deposit for damage?

Usually only for what your agreement allows and what you can show. Photos at check-in and check-out and a repair cost are the evidence. Check any cap or rule in your city.

What if the resident files a consumer complaint?

Respond to every notice and attend. Ignoring notices let a forum decide a Greater Noida hostel case without the hostel. Take advice from a lawyer who handles consumer cases.

Where these numbers come from

  1. Deposit paid vs returned by a tenant group after six months: a group of tenants paid ₹31,500 in deposits and got ₹15,000 back after six months (one Bengaluru PG) (Bengaluru PG). Reported: The News Minute, Deposit paid vs returned by a tenant group after six months, checked 14 November 2026.
  2. Advance a resident of one privately owned hostel in Hyderabad was asked to pay, and lose on early exit: 10 months of rent (Hyderabad, privately owned hostel). Reported: The South First, Advance a resident of one privately owned hostel in Hyderabad was asked to pay, and lose on early exit, checked 14 November 2026.
  3. Advance paid / refunded / compensation / costs in Kangra order: a consumer forum in Kangra ordered a Greater Noida hostel to refund ₹30,000 of a ₹35,000 advance with 9 percent interest, plus ₹5,000 compensation and ₹5,000 costs (Himachal consumer forum vs Greater Noida hostel). Reported: Outlook Money, Advance paid / refunded / compensation / costs in Kangra order, checked 14 November 2026.
  4. Limitation for consumer complaint: 2 years from cause of action; condonable for sufficient cause with recorded reasons (s69) (India). Official source: Gazette of India, Limitation for consumer complaint, checked 14 November 2026.
  5. Owner food cost per person: groceries 2,030 + gas 470: about ₹2,500 a month per resident (groceries ₹2,030 plus cooking gas ₹470) (India, PG with 3 meals). Ballpark Groceries ₹68 a day is an estimate (gap); gas = 0.2476 cylinders x ₹1,899

Fees, rates and rents change. Check the official source before you pay or sign anything.

Customers and marketing · PG or paying guest accommodation

More on customers and marketing for a pg or paying guest accommodation

13 pages on this. You are on number 12.

  1. What photos and video make a PG listing fill beds?
  2. A few beds are empty in the middle of the year. How do I fill them?
  3. When do student bookings start, and how should I time my PG's year?
  4. How do I check a new resident's ID, background and references before I accept them?
  5. How do referral discounts work for a PG, and how much should I offer?
  6. Do tie-ups with colleges and coaching institutes fill a PG?
  7. How do I answer a one-star review about my PG's deposit or food?
  8. Do tie-ups with companies and HR teams fill a PG for professionals?
All 13 on customers and marketing →

Reading about it is one thing; doing it in your pg or paying guest accommodation is another. If you'd like a hand bringing in customers, tell us where you are and a person will reply, free.

Get help with this ↓

What now?

Next question · 6 of 8 in Who stays and how to keep themHow do I get honest reviews for my stay, and reply to a bad one? →

Where are you?

One tap, and we point you to the right next step.

Menu

Read

Ask an expert Ask an expertFree, real peopleHub
Ask an expert