Stays · 5 min read

How do I get honest reviews for my stay, and reply to a bad one?

The short answer

Ask every guest or resident for a review at a moment they are happy to give one, make it easy with a link or QR code, and reply to every review within a day or two. Never pay for reviews, never write your own and never pick only the happy guests. For a bad review, reply in three steps: thank them, say what you will check, and move the detail offline. The reply is read by the next guest, not only by the one who complained.

Not sure about your case? Ask an expert, free ↓

Why reviews are the deciding line

A woman moving to a new city for a job reads the three lowest reviews of a PG before she reads anything else. A family booking a homestay for a festival week does the same. They are not looking for perfection; they are looking for what goes wrong and how the owner handled it. A calm, specific reply under a one-star review often reassures them more than another five stars.

A stay also has a quieter problem: the people who write are the ones who left angry or who were asked at a good moment. If you never ask, your public rating is the opinion of your angriest guests.

How to ask without breaking the rules

  • Ask everyone, not a selected few. Google's policy does not allow asking only happy guests or discouraging negative reviews.
  • Make it one tap. Your profile gives you a review link; turn it into a QR code on the check-out slip, the welcome card in the room, the dining area wall or the end of a WhatsApp chat.
  • Ask at the right moment. For a homestay or guest house, the evening before check-out, when the guest has just said something kind. For a PG, after a resident has settled in, not at the first-week deposit conversation, and not while a dispute is open.
  • Do not reward a review. A free meal, a discount on rent or a deposit favour in exchange for a review counts as paying for it under Google's rules.
  • Do not write them yourself or have staff, family or friends write them. Reviews can be removed, and a profile caught doing it can be restricted.
  • Do not hand over your phone to a resident to write a review at your door; it reads as pressure and Google may link the reviews to one device.

Replying to a bad review in three steps

  1. Thank and acknowledge, in one line. 'Thank you for telling us. We are sorry the stay was not what you expected.' No excuses and no 'as per our policy' in the first line.
  2. Say what you will check, without blaming. 'We will look at the water supply on the second floor and the geyser.' If a fact in the review is wrong, say it plainly and once: 'Our records show the stay was from the 3rd to the 12th.' Do not argue the whole case in public.
  3. Move the detail offline. 'Please call us on this number so we can sort this out.' Then do it, and if it is solved, you can add a short line saying so.

Never reveal a guest's or resident's personal details, room number, ID, payment or the content of a private message in a reply. Never threaten a legal case or a police complaint in a public reply. If a review contains something that breaks Google's policy, such as abuse, a conflict of interest or a review for a place the person never stayed in, you can flag it for removal through the profile; a review that is only unflattering stays.

What the review is telling you

Patterns that recur in resident and guest complaints. Reviews are not a measurement; treat these as prompts to check your own place.
What the review saysUsually meansFix
Food is repetitive or wateryA menu that has not changed and a cook with no feedbackWeekly menu, a feedback line to the cook, a monthly tasting by the owner
Bathroom or room not cleanHousekeeping cycle too thin for the occupancyA checklist signed daily, and enough hours of housekeeping for the number of beds
Deposit or charges not explainedTerms said, not writtenWritten receipt for every rupee; deductions with photos on a fixed date
Rude or absent managerOne person covering too many hoursFixed hours, a back-up phone number, and a visible name
Wi-Fi, geyser or water not workingA fault with no logComplaint log with date and fix date, shown to the guest
Photos do not match the roomOld or aspirational picturesRe-shoot; see what photos fill a stay

For homes, small stays and large ones

A homestay with three rooms is reviewed as a person: 'the aunty was lovely'. Keep replies warm and short, in the same voice you speak in. A PG or hostel with fifty beds is reviewed as an institution; replies should come from the owner or manager by name, never from 'the management'. If you run several buildings, a reply that mentions the building and the issue shows you read it.

What usually goes wrong

  • Five reviews arrive from friends in one week and Google removes them, taking real ones with it.
  • A fight with a guest in the reply thread, read by every future guest.
  • A reply that names the guest's room or payment, which is a privacy problem as well as bad taste.
  • Staff replying from a personal account with a different tone.
  • Reviews are never read until a parent mentions one.
  • A 'review for a discount' offer in a WhatsApp group, which is paid reviewing and breaks the rules.

Apply it to your own stay

Read your last ten reviews today. Write down any complaint that appears twice. That is your next repair. Then reply to the oldest unanswered one before you do anything else. If a review has become a dispute about money or a legal threat, take advice before replying, and tell us where you are if you want a second view.

Questions people ask

Can I ask guests for reviews?

Yes. Ask everyone, in the same way, and do not offer anything in return. Do not ask only the guests you think are happy.

Can I get a bad review removed?

Only if it breaks Google's content policy, for example abuse, spam, or a review from someone who never stayed. A review that is only unfair or unflattering stays, which is why your reply matters.

Should I reply to good reviews too?

Yes, briefly. It shows guests that a person reads the profile, and it takes a minute.

A former resident posted a review about the deposit. What do I do?

Reply once, calmly, state that you will check the records, and ask them to call. For the PG-specific version, see the page on answering a one-star review about a PG's deposit or food.

Customers and marketing · Stays

More on customers and marketing for a stays

4 pages on this. You are on number 3.

  1. How do I set up my stay on Google Maps so people call and book?
  2. What photos and video make a stay fill, and what puts people off?
  3. How do I get honest reviews for my stay, and reply to a bad one?
  4. How do I answer WhatsApp enquiries fast without it taking over my day?

Reading about it is one thing; doing it in your stays is another. If you'd like a hand bringing in customers, tell us where you are and a person will reply, free.

Get help with this ↓

What now?

Next question · 3 of 5 in Getting found and trustedHow do I answer WhatsApp enquiries fast without it taking over my day? →

Where are you?

One tap, and we point you to the right next step.

Menu

Read

Ask an expert Ask an expertFree, real peopleHub
Ask an expert