D2C brand · 5 min read

Should I sell on Amazon first or build my own D2C website?

The short answer

Start on a marketplace if people already search for your kind of product there, you are cheap and light to ship, and you want orders and reviews without paying for traffic. Start on your own site if your product is new to the buyer, your edge is the story or the repeat purchase, or you want the customer's name and number. In 2026 the fee side looks kinder: Amazon India charges 0% referral fee under ₹1,000 and Flipkart has 0% commission on products under ₹1,000, though closing, shipping, returns and storage fees still apply. Many brands do both, in a deliberate order.

Not sure about your case? Ask an expert, free ↓

Rs 2.5 lakh, 300 units and a rival

One seller put ₹2.5 lakh into 300 units in 2017, sold them out on Amazon and Flipkart within 50 hours, reordered ₹7.5 lakh of stock to triple it, and reached ₹20 lakh a day at the peak. Later a marketplace-owned rival arrived and sales fell. He said afterwards that he had read the marketplace's interest as proof he was right (Business Today, December 2024). It is one account, from an unnamed founder, not a rule. It shows both halves of the marketplace bargain: fast demand and no ownership of the customer.

The two routes compared

A qualitative comparison. Fee figures are as reported; check your seller dashboard and the platform's current terms.
Marketplace firstOwn site first
TrafficBuyers already searching; you compete on the listingYou pay for every visitor, mostly with ads
Cost to startSeller account, listing, fees per saleA store plan, a gateway and ads; see store cost
Fees that remain after zero commissionClosing, shipping, returns, storage and adsGateway fee 2.36% of order value, plus your own shipping
Customer dataThe marketplace owns itYou own the name, number and history
Repeat and CRMHard to reach buyers againWhatsApp and email flows are yours
Brand controlListing format, rules and reviews set by the platformFull control of look and story
Copy and platform riskThe platform can see what sells; a rival or a private label can appear; accounts can be suspendedAd account risk and a rival can still copy
CashPayouts follow the platform's cycle; blogs say about 7 to 15 days after deliveryPrepaid money arrives with the gateway; COD arrives with the courier
SuitsLow-priced, light, searched productsProducts with a story, a repeat cycle or a higher price

What changed with fees in 2026

Amazon India announced a 0% referral fee on products under ₹1,000 from 16 March 2026. Flipkart announced 0% commission on products under ₹1,000 and on Shopsy from November 2025, and 0% on all fashion from 8 July 2026. Meesho's commission on most categories is 0%, though shipping by weight and zone, returns, RTO and ads still cost sellers.

The headline is zero commission; the bill is not zero. Closing, shipping, collection, return and storage fees remain, and ads on a marketplace cost money too. One 2026 guide puts the real cost of selling on Meesho at 10 to 15% once ads and returns are counted. Policies can reverse by category, so plan margins on the full list of fees from your dashboard, not on the headline. See what changed with zero commission.

Four questions to decide

  • Do buyers already search for this on a marketplace? If yes, a listing meets demand. If not, ads on your own site create it.
  • Can you ship it cheaply? A light, small, low-risk product suits marketplace logistics. A fragile, bulky or fit-sensitive one needs your control.
  • Do you want the repeat? If the money is in the second and third order, own the customer from the start.
  • Can you stand a rival copying you? If the product is easy to copy, a marketplace shows it to every copier; see can a marketplace copy my top seller.

Three yes answers to the first, second and fourth point to marketplace first. A yes on the third points to your own site.

An order that many brands follow

  1. Test cheaply on a marketplace listing or a pre-order page; see how to test before you stock.
  2. Build the own site as soon as repeat orders show, and collect numbers for WhatsApp and email.
  3. Move repeat buyers to the own site with a card in the parcel and an offer, within the marketplace's rules.
  4. Keep the marketplace for discovery and the own site for margin and repeat.
  5. Spread the risk so no channel is above about two-thirds of orders; that is a rule of thumb, not a published threshold.

See how to avoid depending on one channel.

What usually goes wrong

  • Choosing a marketplace because it looks free and finding ads, returns and storage are not.
  • Putting all stock on one platform and having nothing for your own site.
  • Building a website and waiting for traffic that never comes without a budget.
  • Ignoring registration: selling through an e-commerce operator needs a GST registration in most cases; see GST for marketplace sellers.
  • Reading a quick sell-out as a forecast.

Apply it to your product

Answer the four questions for your product on one page and pick a first channel. If you choose a marketplace, plan the second step on day one. Tell us where you are if you want to talk it through. Next, see which marketplaces to sell on or which store to build.

Questions people ask

Is zero commission on Amazon and Flipkart real?

For products under ₹1,000 in many categories, yes, but closing, shipping, returns and storage fees still apply, and rules can change by category. Check your own fee calculator.

Can I get my marketplace customers onto my own site?

Only within the marketplace's rules. A card in the parcel and a clear offer are common; check what the platform allows.

Should I do both from day one?

Not at the start. Test with one, then add the second once you know your numbers.

Where these numbers come from

  1. Amazon India referral fee on products priced under ₹1,000: 0% (India, 1,800+ categories, from 16 March 2026; closing, shipping and storage fees still apply). Official source: Amazon India press release (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.
  2. Flipkart commission on products under ₹1,000 and on Shopsy: 0% (India, from November 2025; fixed, collection, shipping and return fees still apply). Reported: business-standard.com (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.
  3. Payment gateway fee on cards, UPI and netbanking: 2.36% of order value (all India; 2% plus 18% GST on the fee; one gateway's published rate). Reported: Razorpay blog (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.
  4. Flipkart commission on all fashion: 0% (India, from 8 July 2026). Official source: stories.flipkart.com (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.
  5. Meesho commission on most categories: 0% (India; shipping by weight and zone, returns, RTO and ads still cost sellers; one 2026 guide puts the real cost at 10 to 15% with ads and returns). Reported: inc42.com (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.

Fees, rates and rents change. Check the official source before you pay or sign anything.

Place and setup · D2C brand

More on place and setup for a d2c brand

11 pages on this. You are on number 10.

  1. How do I know people will buy my D2C product before I make a batch of stock?
  2. When should my D2C brand move to a 3PL or fulfilment centre, and what does it cost?
  3. Is marketplace fulfilment such as Amazon FBA worth it for a small D2C brand?
  4. Is white-labelling cheating? Will my D2C customers find out?
  5. What packing, shipping and fulfilment cost per order for a D2C brand in India
  6. Why do D2C brands fail in the first year in India, and how do I avoid it?
  7. Should I sell on Amazon first or build my own D2C website?
  8. I already sell this in my shop. How do I turn it into a D2C brand?
All 11 on place and setup →

Reading about it is one thing; doing it in your d2c brand is another. If you'd like a hand choosing and setting up the right place, tell us where you are and a person will reply, free.

Get help with this ↓

What now?

Next question · 6 of 10 in Should I start a D2C brand?What margin should a product have before it is worth building a D2C brand around? →

Where are you?

One tap, and we point you to the right next step.

Menu

Read

Ask an expert Ask an expertFree, real peopleHub
Ask an expert