Read first
The product you love and the margin you do not know
You love the product, the maker's sample is good, and a friend says it will sell. Before you buy a batch, run a short screen. Many brands that fail in the first year do not fail on taste; they fail because the margin cannot carry ads, shipping and returns. A margin test costs an hour. A failed first batch costs months.
The five-check screen
| Check | Question to ask | A good sign | A warning sign |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Gross margin | After landed cost, what share of the net price is left? | 60% or more; see gross margin target | Under 50%, with ads in the plan |
| 2. Shipping weight | What does it cost to send, as a share of the price? | A small, light pack | Heavy or bulky for the price; shipping takes a fifth of the bill |
| 3. Repeat potential | Does it run out, or does someone need another? | A consumable or a gift that people reorder | A once-in-years purchase |
| 4. Return risk | Will people send it back? | No size or fit problem; easy to check on the page | Fit-sensitive; a reported fashion return rate of 15–35% of delivered orders |
| 5. Copyability | Could a rival make it in a week from the same factory? | Your own formula, design or pattern; see who owns the formula | A generic white-label product; a copycat arrives at half the price |
Vendor pages report gross margins of about 60 to 80% in beauty and 50 to 70% in fashion. They are not audited. Use them to see where your product sits, not as a promise.
How to run the screen in an hour
- Get a written quote from the maker at your intended batch size and work out landed cost.
- Calculate gross margin on the net price without GST.
- Look up what a similar product sells for on marketplaces; if you must sell below that to get traffic, adjust.
- Weigh the packed product and ask a courier or aggregator for the rate to three pincodes.
- Ask: would a happy customer buy this again in the next three months?
- Ask: could a copy sit next to mine on a marketplace next month?
If you have only an idea, run a cheap demand test first: test before you stock.
If the margin is thin, what then
A thin margin does not always kill a product. It limits which channel can work: a low-margin product cannot carry quick-commerce commission or heavy paid ads. It may work as a shop or distributor product, or as an add-on in a bundle with a high-margin hero. Or it may be a good second product, not a first one. If you are a shop owner, turning a shop product into a brand uses margin you already know.
If you are small, or already bigger
A starter brand needs the margin screen most, because it has the least cash to absorb a bad bet. A brand adding a second product should hold it to the same screen, and ask whether it lifts the average order value of the hero. A white-label brand should add a sixth check: what exactly makes this product yours, since the maker may sell the same item to others.
What usually goes wrong
- Using the maker's price as the cost.
- Judging margin on price including GST.
- Picking a product because it sells on a marketplace, with no view of the seller's margin.
- Treating a viral post as demand.
- Ignoring shipping weight until the first courier bill.
- Believing a lower COGS next year will fix this year's margin.
This page is general information, not financial advice. Margin thresholds are analyst readings and our own screen; test with your own quotes.
Score your product
If it passes, price it carefully: price your product. To check your numbers, tell us what you plan to sell.
Questions people ask
Is a 40% margin ever enough?
It can be for a brand with low ad spend, high repeat and few returns, selling mostly through shops or its own network. With paid ads and COD it is usually too thin.
Which categories have the highest margins?
Vendor pages report beauty at 60 to 80% and fashion at 50 to 70%. These are not audited and vary by product.
Should I choose margin over passion?
Choose a product you understand, but check that the margin supports the way you plan to sell it.
These are ballpark figures to plan with, not a forecast for your business. Your own quotes and numbers come first.
Where these numbers come from
- Gross margin that lets a brand carry ads and returns: 60% or more; 70% or more copes best with quick commerce (India; analyst reading of 34 brands). Ballpark The CPG Lab Substack scan of 34 Indian D2C brands (2026) read gross margin off filings; the analyst's own judgement, not a rule.
- Customer return rate after delivery, fashion: 15–35% of delivered orders (all India; agency blog 15 to 25, base.com 20 to 35; not audited). Reported: base.com blog (checked research 2026-11-14), checked 13 November 2026.
Fees, rates and rents change. Check the official source before you pay or sign anything.
Money and tax · D2C brand
More on money and tax for a d2c brand
33 pages on this. You are on number 30.
- Is it okay to lose money on the first order to win a repeat customer?
- Presumptive tax or a Pvt Ltd: which suits a growing D2C brand?
- What a D2C brand costs to launch in its first 90 days: bootstrap, lean and proper, one product
- What gross margin does a D2C brand need to survive ads and returns?
- What margin should a product have before it is worth building a D2C brand around?
- How do I work out my D2C brand's customer lifetime value?
- Do I need a co-founder to start a D2C brand?
- How much do shipping, packaging and payment fees add to each D2C order?
Reading about it is one thing; doing it in your d2c brand is another. If you'd like a hand working out your own numbers, tell us where you are and a person will reply, free.
Get help with this ↓What now?
Where are you?
One tap, and we point you to the right next step.