Read first
Carton 14 of 40
A batch arrives on a Saturday. The owner signs the delivery slip, stacks the cartons, and starts packing orders on Monday. On Wednesday a customer sends a photo of a split seam, and by Friday there are eleven. When she opens carton 14 she finds a whole run with the same fault. The maker says the delivery slip was signed without remark, so the goods were accepted.
A signature on a slip is often treated as acceptance. A check at the door costs an hour. A bad batch discovered through customers costs refunds, reviews and the stock itself.
Set up three things before the first batch
- A written standard. One page: dimensions and tolerance, weight, shade, material or ingredient list, pack, label position, shelf life where it applies. Signed by you and the maker. See how to check the factory.
- Sealed approved samples. Two: one you keep, one with the maker.
- A tracking sheet. A row per batch: date, batch number, quantity, result, photos, notes.
Ask the maker to put a batch number or manufacturing date on every carton. If a problem appears later, the batch number is how you find which units are affected.
The five checks, on delivery day
| Check | How | What a fail looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Count | Count cartons against the invoice, then open and count one carton fully | Short quantity, or mixed variants in one carton |
| Outside | Look at cartons for damp, crushing, tape cuts | Wet cartons, crushed corners, broken seals |
| Match | Compare 10 to 20 random pieces with the sealed sample and the standard, in daylight | Shade or size off, finish rough, wrong fragrance or taste |
| Function | Use a few as a customer would: wear, wash, open, close, fill, spray | Leaks, loose seams, broken closures |
| Check label content, MRP, quantity, dates, address and customer-care details on a few units | Wrong MRP, missing declarations, blurred print |
Check the label with particular care. Wrong declarations on a packaged product are an offence under Legal Metrology rules, and since 1 May 2026 the penalty is a warning first, then up to First offence: warning by improvement notice. Second: up to ₹5,00,000. Third and later: ₹25,00,000 to ₹50,00,000. It is far cheaper to catch a mispriced label on delivery than after it has gone out in a thousand parcels. See label declarations.
When a batch fails
- Quarantine it. Mark the cartons "hold" and keep them away from good stock.
- Photograph and measure the fault against your standard and sealed sample.
- Tell the maker in writing the same day. A message with photos and the batch number. Calls get forgotten.
- Decide what you want: replacement, rework, credit note or refund. For a partial fault, sort and return only the bad part.
- Agree it in writing before any rework starts, including who pays freight and by what date.
- Do not sell the faulty units unless the fault is cosmetic, you have agreed a lower price with the maker and the product is labelled honestly.
- Update your tracking sheet and decide whether this maker gets another order.
If some of the batch has already shipped, the principle is the same everywhere: stop the sale, count how many units are out using the batch number, and contact those buyers yourself before a review does. Offer a replacement or refund without making them argue for it.
What usually goes wrong
- Signing for delivery without opening anything. Write "received subject to inspection" on the slip.
- Checking only the top carton. Faults often follow a production run, not a carton.
- Having no retained sample, so you cannot show what the batch looked like on arrival.
- Telling the maker by phone and never in writing.
- Fixing the product but not the standard, so the next batch repeats the fault.
Keep a retained sample of every batch for at least as long as the product's shelf life or warranty. When a customer complains a year later, it is the only proof of what you sent.
Apply it to your next batch
Before the next delivery, write the one-page standard, set up the tracking sheet, and decide who opens the cartons. If a batch has already gone wrong and you are unsure how to talk to the maker, tell us where you are.
Questions people ask
How many units should I inspect from a batch?
For a batch of a few hundred, 10 to 20 random pieces across several cartons is a practical minimum. For larger batches ask the maker what they check and consider a formal sampling table.
Can I reject a batch after I have signed for delivery?
It becomes harder to argue, which is why you write 'received subject to inspection' on the slip and inspect the same day. What you can reject depends on your agreement with the maker, so keep terms in writing.
What is a retained sample?
One or two units from each batch that you keep sealed and labelled with the batch number, so you can later show what that batch was like.
Where these numbers come from
- Penalty for a wrong Legal Metrology declaration on a packaged product: First offence: warning by improvement notice. Second: up to ₹5,00,000. Third and later: ₹25,00,000 to ₹50,00,000 (all India; in force from 1 May 2026 (Jan Vishwas Act 2026)). Official source: Jan Vishwas (Amendment of Provisions) Act 2026, Schedule serial 66; S.O. 2103(E), checked 13 November 2026.
Fees, rates and rents change. Check the official source before you pay or sign anything.
Operations · Product brands
More on operations for a product brands
16 pages on this. You are on number 16.
- Which courier or shipping aggregator should your brand use in India?
- Minimum order quantity and samples: how to get a smaller first order from a maker
- What is an NDR in shipping, and what should your brand do when a delivery attempt fails?
- How to pack products so they arrive unbroken without overspending on packaging
- What happens when a courier loses or damages your customer's parcel?
- How many units should your brand make in its first batch?
- How should your brand set a return and refund policy in India, and what must it honour by law?
- How to check quality on every batch of your brand's product, and what to do when one is bad
and 8 more.
Reading about it is one thing; doing it in your product brands is another. If you'd like a hand running it smoothly day to day, tell us where you are and a person will reply, free.
Get help with this ↓What now?
Where are you?
One tap, and we point you to the right next step.
What to read next
Related questions
For your kind of business
- D2C brandA bad batch is already sold. What do I do for the customers and the brand?→
- D2C brandThe factory changed the material or formula without telling me. What now?→
- D2C brandWhat should a D2C brand have ready in the last two weeks before launch?→
- D2C brandHow do I write SOPs so my D2C brand runs without me?→