Read first
The same product, a rival's name
A founder sees a competitor's launch post and recognises the jar, the finish and even the shade of the cap. She calls her maker, who says, with some surprise, "we make this for many people". She had not asked; he had not offered. We found no documented named case of this in the founder accounts we read, but trade explainers say the same thing: in white and private label the maker often keeps the base product and can sell it on.
What you own, and what you can stop
| What the maker is selling | Who owns it | Can you stop it? |
|---|---|---|
| A catalogue product with your label | The maker | No. It is theirs to sell, unless a signed exclusivity says otherwise |
| A private-label base with your changes | The maker owns the base; you may own the changes if written down | Only the parts you own, and only if the agreement says so |
| Your formula or pattern, given to them in confidence | You, if you can show you created it | Maybe, if there is a written confidentiality or non-use clause and you can prove the copy |
| Your registered brand name or logo | You, as the trademark owner | Yes: they cannot use your brand on others' goods |
| Your packaging design, if registered | You, with a design registration | Possibly; see the page on someone copying your design |
Whatever the contract says, a trademark is separate. File your name before launch if you can; see the trademark question. A maker who sells the same generic product under a different brand is not breaking your trademark, but one who sells it under yours or a confusingly similar one is.
What to do now
- Check your paperwork. What did you sign? Any exclusivity, confidentiality or non-compete? Any message in which the maker promised not to sell it? Messages count as evidence but are weaker than a signed clause.
- Do not threaten first. Ask the maker what they are selling and to whom. A calm call finds out whether they copied your spec or sold the same catalogue item.
- Compare the products. If the rival's product is your custom spec, that may be a breach and you should talk to a lawyer. If it is a catalogue item, there is nothing to stop.
- Look at what you own: trademark, label design, claims, photos, copy. Check the rival is not using them.
- Decide what you want: exclusivity going forward (for a price or a volume commitment), a different product, or a different maker.
- Do not stop buying until you have a replacement, or stock will run out.
How to make the next product harder to copy
- Ask for exclusivity up front, and expect to pay for it with a minimum yearly volume or a higher price. Put it in the manufacturing agreement.
- Own your spec. Write the formula, pattern or design, date it and keep it. See who owns the formula.
- Register your trademark before launch and keep your label design consistent.
- Keep a second maker qualified on a small order.
- Differentiate beyond the product: pack, story, service, claims you can back, community. A rival can copy a bottle; it is harder to copy a brand.
- Do not share more than needed. Give a maker your full spec only after a confidentiality clause.
When a copy shows up on a marketplace, see a lawyer who handles trade mark and design disputes, and read what to do when a copycat sells at half the price.
What usually goes wrong
- Assuming exclusivity because the maker was friendly.
- Paying a large advance on an exclusive promise that is not in the quote.
- Sharing a full formula before any clause is signed.
- Moving to a new maker without the spec, so the product changes.
- Fighting the maker instead of building the brand. Customers do not buy a formula; they buy a name they trust.
General information, not legal advice. If a custom spec has clearly been copied and you have a signed agreement, speak to a lawyer who handles commercial contracts.
Apply it to your maker
Look at your agreement and your message history with the maker today. If you find no exclusivity and no confidentiality clause, decide which of the changes above you can make in the next order. Tell us where you are if you want a hand drafting the terms or planning a switch.
Questions people ask
Can a manufacturer sell my product to others?
Unless a signed agreement says otherwise, a maker generally can sell a product it developed or a catalogue product to anyone. Your brand name is yours; the product may not be.
How do I get exclusivity?
Ask for it before the first order and expect to pay with a volume commitment or a higher price. Get it in a signed agreement.
Does a trademark stop a factory from selling the same product?
No. It stops others using your brand name on their goods. The product itself needs a contract clause or a formula, pattern or design you own.
Operations · D2C brand
More on operations for a d2c brand
23 pages on this. You are on number 20.
- Which order, shipping and returns tools does a small D2C brand need?
- How much advance should a D2C brand pay a maker, and how do I protect it?
- What should a D2C brand have ready in the last two weeks before launch?
- Can I start a D2C brand while keeping my job?
- The factory sells the same product to someone else. Can my D2C brand stop it?
- The factory changed the material or formula without telling my D2C brand. What now?
- A bad batch is already sold. What should my D2C brand do for the customers and the brand?
- Should my D2C brand make its own product, or use a contract maker?
Reading about it is one thing; doing it in your d2c brand is another. If you'd like a hand running it smoothly day to day, tell us where you are and a person will reply, free.
Get help with this ↓What now?
Where are you?
One tap, and we point you to the right next step.