Read first
Fourteen complaints by Friday
A batch of 400 units went out over three weeks. By Friday there are fourteen messages: a seam that opened, a cap that leaks, a smell that is wrong. The owner replies to each one separately with an apology and a new unit. By the following Wednesday it is thirty-one, a review thread has a photo, and she realises that she does not know how many of the 400 are affected or where they went.
We found no sourced named case with a rupee figure, so this scene is a composite. What it shows is the order of work: count first, then talk to people.
The first 48 hours
- Stop. Hold unshipped units of the batch. Pause ads and listings for the affected item if you cannot ship good units.
- Find the batch number on cartons and units and match it to orders. Use your store export to list every order that contains it.
- Assess the fault. Cosmetic, functional or safety? Does it make a label claim untrue? A safety or health risk is a different matter from a loose stitch.
- Preserve evidence. Photos, the retained sample from the batch, customer messages, the delivery slip and your arrival check.
- Tell the maker in writing the same day, with photos and the batch number. See what to do when the factory changed the material.
- Decide your offer: replacement, refund or both, free of cost to the customer, with free return pickup if you want the unit back.
Is it a recall?
If the product could harm health or safety, or contravenes a rule such as a banned ingredient or a missing mandatory warning, treat it as a recall: stop sales, contact every buyer, collect the units and tell the relevant regulator where the category requires it. Food, cosmetics, electrical goods and children's products each have their own rules and authorities, and we have not opened them here: check with the category regulator and a lawyer before you decide that a safety problem can be handled as ordinary customer service.
Consumer protection law also lets buyers complain about defective goods and misleading claims. A fast, fair refund is both the right thing and the cheapest path.
General information, not legal advice. For anything that could hurt a customer, speak to a lawyer and the category's regulator.
Talk to the customers yourself
- Write one honest message: what happened, which units are affected, what you will do, by when.
- Send it by WhatsApp or email to every buyer in the batch, not only those who complained.
- Offer the remedy without a fight. Do not ask for proof beyond a photo.
- Give a single contact number for questions.
- Follow up when the replacement ships.
Customers who get a quick, no-argument fix often buy again; those who find out from a review do not. Published founder accounts describe tracking return reasons by phone and feeding them into the next batch as a lasting habit of brands that survive; see how to turn returns into a better next batch.
Reviews and the public
- Reply to each public review with a short, human answer and the fix. Do not argue and do not delete honest reviews.
- Do not offer free product in exchange for deleting a review. That can breach marketplace rules.
- Pin or post a short note about the issue and the remedy if many people are affected.
- Fix the listing. If a claim or photo no longer matches the product, change it now.
Recover from the maker, and count the cost
| Cost line | Record it |
|---|---|
| Replacement units | Landed cost times units sent |
| Refunds | Amounts refunded |
| Freight both ways | Courier invoices |
| Handling time | Hours at a fair rate |
| Lost sales while stock was held | Estimate from normal sales |
| Lab test, if any | Invoice |
Send the maker a written claim with the sheet and your evidence, and agree credit, replacement or refund. If your agreement is thin, use it to tighten the next one; see the manufacturing agreement and quality control on every batch.
What usually goes wrong
- Replying to complaints one by one and never counting how many are affected.
- Not knowing which orders had the faulty batch because the batch number was never recorded.
- Waiting for the maker to agree before helping the customer.
- Hiding the issue until a review exposes it.
- Fixing the batch and not the cause, so the next one repeats it.
Apply it to your batch
If this is live now, start with the numbered steps. If not, do the preventive work: record batch numbers against orders and keep a retained sample of every batch. Tell us where you are if you want help with the customer message or the claim.
Questions people ask
Do I have to recall a defective batch?
If the fault could harm health or safety, or breaks a mandatory rule, treat it as a recall and check the category regulator's rules. For a non-safety fault, a prompt replacement or refund is the right course.
How do I find which customers got the bad batch?
Match the batch number to your order records. If you did not record it, narrow by dispatch dates and ask the maker which cartons went out in which window. Record batch numbers from now on.
Can I recover the cost from the maker?
Often, if you have a written standard, evidence and a claim backed by a cost sheet. How much depends on your agreement.
Operations · D2C brand
More on operations for a d2c brand
23 pages on this. You are on number 22.
- Which order, shipping and returns tools does a small D2C brand need?
- How much advance should a D2C brand pay a maker, and how do I protect it?
- What should a D2C brand have ready in the last two weeks before launch?
- Can I start a D2C brand while keeping my job?
- The factory sells the same product to someone else. Can my D2C brand stop it?
- The factory changed the material or formula without telling my D2C brand. What now?
- A bad batch is already sold. What should my D2C brand do for the customers and the brand?
- Should my D2C brand make its own product, or use a contract maker?
Reading about it is one thing; doing it in your d2c brand is another. If you'd like a hand running it smoothly day to day, tell us where you are and a person will reply, free.
Get help with this ↓What now?
Where are you?
One tap, and we point you to the right next step.