Read first
The second batch feels different
The first batch of a cream was smooth and mild. The second smells stronger and a few customers write that it stings. The fabric of a kurti feels thinner than the first lot. Nothing on the invoice has changed. The maker says it is "the same product", or that the old supplier's material was unavailable and the new one is "equivalent". You are now selling something you did not approve.
We found no named case of this in the founder accounts we read, so this scene is a composite, not one owner's story. The pattern is familiar to anyone who has used a contract maker: quality drifts when no one is checking, and substitutions happen when a material price rises or a supplier runs short. The question is what you can show.
Step by step
- Stop the sale of the affected batch. Hold cartons that have not shipped. If some have, note the batch number.
- Compare against your records. Sealed approved sample, written standard, last batch's retained sample, invoice and specification sheet. Photograph differences side by side.
- Test if it matters. For ingredients or fabric composition, a lab report from an accredited lab gives you proof the maker cannot easily dispute. It costs money; use it if the stakes are high.
- Write to the maker the same day. State the batch number, what differs, the evidence and what you want. Keep the tone factual.
- Choose the remedy. Replacement with the approved material, rework, a price cut if the change is minor and you choose to sell, or refund of that batch.
- Agree it in writing before anyone starts, with dates and who pays freight.
- Check your label and claims. If the product no longer matches what the label says, you cannot sell it as labelled.
- Tell affected customers if the product has shipped and could harm them or differs from what they bought. Offer a replacement or refund without making them argue.
Do you have to tell customers?
If the change affects safety, an allergen, a regulated claim or something the label promises, yes: stop selling and contact buyers. For categories such as food and cosmetics, regulators have their own rules on recalls and labelling; check the category rules and, where needed, a lawyer. If the change is minor and the product still matches the label and claims, you may decide to continue, but do not hide it if customers ask.
This page is general information, not legal advice. A change that affects safety or a legal claim needs a lawyer and the category regulator's rules.
What the maker may say, and what you can answer
| The maker says | What to ask | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| The old material was not available | Why were you not told before production? | Insist on written approval for any change next time; ask for the old material or a replacement made right |
| It is equivalent | On what basis, and who tested it? | Compare to your standard; get a test if needed |
| The sample was hand-made | Then what is the bulk spec? | Re-sign a bulk standard with tolerances |
| You signed the delivery slip | Was it signed subject to inspection? | Check your records; write the claim anyway |
| It is within tolerance | Show me the tolerance | A written tolerance is why you wrote one |
How to stop it happening again
- A clause that any change in material, ingredient, supplier or process needs your written approval before production; see the manufacturing agreement.
- A written standard with tolerances, signed by both of you.
- A sealed approved sample with the maker and one with you.
- A check of every batch on arrival; see quality control per batch.
- A retained sample of every batch.
- A second maker qualified on a small order, so you have an exit.
- A relationship: a maker who is told what quality means to your brand and visited now and then is less likely to cut corners quietly.
What usually goes wrong
- Having no standard, so "equivalent" cannot be argued.
- Having no retained sample and no photos.
- Selling the batch because stock is short, then dealing with returns.
- Arguing by phone and never in writing.
- Switching makers in anger without a replacement ready, leaving a stock gap.
If you have already sold units from the batch, see what to do about a bad batch that is already sold.
Apply it to your batch
If this is happening now, start with step one and the written message. If you do not have a standard yet, write one this week for your next order. If you want help with the message or the next maker, tell us where you are.
Questions people ask
Can I get a refund if the maker changed the material?
That depends on your agreement and what you can prove. A written standard, a sealed sample and photos give you the strongest position. Ask for replacement or credit in writing.
Should I get a lab test?
If the change affects safety, claims or a large batch, yes. A lab report is hard to dispute. For a cosmetic difference, side-by-side comparison may be enough.
Do I have to tell customers?
If the change affects safety, an allergen or something the label promises, stop selling and contact buyers. For anything else, use your judgement and be honest if asked.
Operations · D2C brand
More on operations for a d2c brand
23 pages on this. You are on number 21.
- Which order, shipping and returns tools does a small D2C brand need?
- How much advance should a D2C brand pay a maker, and how do I protect it?
- What should a D2C brand have ready in the last two weeks before launch?
- Can I start a D2C brand while keeping my job?
- The factory sells the same product to someone else. Can my D2C brand stop it?
- The factory changed the material or formula without telling my D2C brand. What now?
- A bad batch is already sold. What should my D2C brand do for the customers and the brand?
- Should my D2C brand make its own product, or use a contract maker?
Reading about it is one thing; doing it in your d2c brand is another. If you'd like a hand running it smoothly day to day, tell us where you are and a person will reply, free.
Get help with this ↓What now?
Where are you?
One tap, and we point you to the right next step.